OBJECTIVE: To assess whether late orchidopexy for undescended testis represents delayed treatment of primary undescended testis or later-occurring acquired undescended testis. STUDY DESIGN: We examined boys undergoing orchidopexy for cryptorchidism regarding age at surgery and entity of undescended testis. We characterized differences between primary undescended testis and acquired undescended testis and evaluated the knowledge regarding the diagnosis and management of acquired undescended testis among practicing physicians. We conducted an observational study using a mixed-method multicenter cross-sectional design. A total of 310 consecutive boys undergoing orchidopexy for undescended testis at 6 pediatric medical centers in Germany between April 2016 and June 2018 were investigated regarding testicular position at birth and age at surgery. In addition, a survey on acquired undescended testis management was carried out in 1017 multidisciplinary physicians and final-year medical students. RESULTS: Only 13% of all patients were operated on in their first year of life. Among patients with known previous testicular position (67%), primary undescended testis (n = 103) and acquired undescended testis (n = 104) were equally frequent. More than one-half (56%) of orchidopexies performed after the first year of life were due to acquired undescended testis. Remarkably, only 15% of physicians considered acquired undescended testis as an indication for late surgery. CONCLUSIONS: Acquired undescended testis is more common than previously perceived and accounts for a significant proportion of "late" orchidopexies in patients with undescended testis. Acquired undescended testis needs to be better recognized in clinical practice and screening should continue in older children with previously descended testes. TRIAL REGISTRATION: German Clinical Trials Registry: DRKS00015903.