Dimethylsulfoniopropionate (DMSP) and related organic sulfur compounds play key roles in global sulfur cycling. Bacteria have been found to be important DMSP producers in seawater and surface sediments of the aphotic Mariana Trench (MT). However, detailed bacterial DMSP cycling in the Mariana Trench subseafloor remains largely unknown. Here, the bacterial DMSP-cycling potential in a Mariana Trench sediment core (7.5 m in length) obtained at a 10,816-m water depth was investigated using culture-dependent and -independent methods. The DMSP content fluctuated along the sediment depth and reached the highest concentration at 15 to 18 cm below the seafloor (cmbsf). dsyB was the dominant known DMSP synthetic gene, existing in 0.36 to 1.19% of the bacteria, and was identified in the metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs) of previously unknown bacterial DMSP synthetic groups such as Acidimicrobiia, Phycisphaerae, and Hydrogenedentia. dddP, dmdA, and dddX were the major DMSP catabolic genes. The DMSP catabolic activities of DddP and DddX retrieved from Anaerolineales MAGs were confirmed by heterologous expression, indicating that such anaerobic bacteria might participate in DMSP catabolism. Moreover, genes involved in methanethiol (MeSH) production from methylmercaptopropionate (MMPA) and dimethyl sulfide (DMS), MeSH oxidation, and DMS production were highly abundant, suggesting active conversions between different organic sulfur compounds. Finally, most culturable DMSP synthetic and catabolic isolates possessed no known DMSP synthetic and catabolic genes, and actinomycetes could be important groups involved in both DMSP synthesis and catabolism in Mariana Trench sediment. This study extends the current understanding of DMSP cycling in Mariana Trench sediment and highlights the need to uncover novel DMSP metabolic genes/pathways in extreme environments. IMPORTANCE Dimethylsulfoniopropionate (DMSP) is an abundant organosulfur molecule in the ocean and is the precursor for the climate-active volatile gas dimethyl sulfide. Previous studies focused mainly on bacterial DMSP cycling in seawater, coastal sediment, and surface trench sediment samples, but DMSP metabolism in the Mariana Trench (MT) subseafloor sediments remains unknown. Here, we describe the DMSP content and metabolic bacterial groups in the subseafloor of the MT sediment. We found that the tendency for vertical variation of the DMSP content in the MT was distinct from that of the continent shelf sediment. Although dsyB and dddP were the dominant DMSP synthetic and catabolic genes in the MT sediment, respectively, both metagenomic and culture methods revealed multiple previously unknown DMSP metabolic bacterial groups, especially anaerobic bacteria and actinomycetes. The active conversion of DMSP, DMS, and methanethiol may also occur in the MT sediments. These results provide novel insights for understanding DMSP cycling in the MT.