Current management of subclavian artery (SA) lesions is controversial. Subclavian-to-carotid artery transposition (SCT) may be challenging but exhibits unparalleled long-term results. Stent-supported percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (sPTA) is technically easier but not always feasible. Long-term results and comparisons have not been published. We compared both methods performed by vascular surgeons. Data were collected prospectively with retrospective analysis at a tertiary-care center. sPTA was performed through a retrograde transbrachial access using self-expanding nitinol stents. Open surgery was SCT only. Society for Vascular Surgery/International Society of Cardiovascular Surgery reporting standards were applied. Seventy-four patients underwent treatment from January 1995 to August 2007 (median age 62.6 years, 40 female; left-sided pathology 60 [81.1%]; risk factors: hypertension 45 [60.8%], dyslipidemia 47 [63.5%], diabetes 21 [28.4%], smoking 43 [58.1%], SA occlusion 50 [67.6%]). Forty patients (54.1%) underwent primary sPTA (62.5% occlusions) and 34 SCT (73.5% occlusions). The two groups were comparable with regard to risk factors. In 12 patients occlusions could not be recanalized (30%), and in two stents failed within 1 month (both for stenosis). All but one underwent subsequent uneventful SCT. All SCTs were successful. No risk factor could be identified for treatment failure except sPTA (p = 0.002, Fisher's exact test). Median follow-up was 50.1 months with sPTA and 52.6 months with SCT. No procedure failed during follow-up in either group. sPTA can be performed successfully by surgeons. Primary sPTA failed in 48% of occlusions (30% of all sPTAs). Prediction of failure is not possible. According to our experience, we recommend primary sPTA for SA stenosis and surgery for SA occlusions.