RESUMO

Study design: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Objective: To compare the complication rates associated with anterior and posterior approaches for the surgical treatment of unstable hangman's fractures. Methods: A systematic review and meta-analysis were performed following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines in PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus databases to identify comparative studies reporting complications of anterior versus posterior approaches for the treatment of unstable hangman's fractures. Results: The search yielded 1163 papers from which 5 studies were fully included. One hundred fifteen (115) patients were operated on using an anterior approach versus 65 through a posterior approach. The average complication rates for the anterior and posterior approaches were 26.1 % and 13.8 %, respectively. No complications following the anterior approach required pharmacological or surgical intervention (Clavien-Dindo, Grade 1), while 88.9 % of complications following the posterior approach did (Clavien-Dindo, Grade 2). Conclusion: No significant differences in the complication rates were found when comparing anterior versus posterior surgery for treating a C2 traumatic spondylolisthesis. However, most of the complications presented in the posterior surgery group were more severe.

RESUMO

RESUMEN Se trata de un paciente masculino de 85 años de edad, que sufrió una caída y fue inmovilizado y trasladado al servicio de urgencia; refería dolor cervical y rigidez del cuello. Al examen neurológico no se constata déficit neurológico, salvo la contractura de la musculatura cervical. Se le diagnosticó espondilolistesis traumática del axis grado III confirmada mediante estudios radiográficos. Se le realizó abordaje anterior retrofaríngeo extendido con fijación con láminas y tornillos C2-3. El paciente utilizó ortesis rígida externa durante 4 semanas. Su evolución fue favorable(AU)

ABSTRACT This is an 85-year-old male patient who fell and was immobilized and transferred to the emergency department. He complained of neck pain and neck stiffness. Neurological examination revealed no neurological deficit, except for the contracture of the cervical musculature. Traumatic spondylolisthesis of the axis grade III confirmed by radiographic studies was diagnosed. An extended anterior retropharyngeal approach was performed with fixation with blades and C2-3 screws. The patient wore a rigid external orthosis for 4 weeks. His evolution was favorable(AU)

Assuntos

RESUMO

PURPOSE: Over 170 years ago, traumatic spondylolisthesis of the axis or hangman's fracture was described. Most descriptions of this entity have focused on adult presentations. METHODS: We review the literature on pediatric cases of hangman's fracture emphasizing the embryological as well as presentation aspects. RESULTS: The majority of cervical spine fractures in children occur at C1 and C2 vertebrae. A normal anterolisthesis of C2 can be seen in younger children and can mimic the anterolisthesis seen after traumatic spondylolisthesis. CONCLUSIONS: Traumatic spondylolisthesis of the axis in children requires further investigation due to the current emphasis in the literature on adult clinical findings and diagnostic challenges from the developmental immaturity of the pediatric skeleton.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Objetivo: Reportar 3 casos de espondilolistesis traumáticas de L5-S1, una entidad infrecuente, con pocos casos publicados en la literatura. Material y métodos: Se revisaron las historias clínicas de 3 pacientes operados por espondilolistesis traumáticas L5-S1 en el período 2010-2015. Caso 1, varón de 30 años que sufrió una caída del caballo, anterolistesis grado II. Se realizó una artrodesis L4-S2 con realineación y soporte anterior con TLIF L5-S1. Caso 2, varón de 38 años que consultó por lumbalgia intensa luego de accidente automovilístico. Se diagnosticó una anterolistesis grado II con fractura de la base de ambas facetas ascendentes de S1. Se realizó artrodesis L5-S1 con liberación radicular y realineación. Caso 3, varón de 12 años derivado 20 días luego de un politraumatismo por el derrumbe de una pared. Se diagnosticó una espondilolistesis con dislocación facetaria bilateral. Se realizó una artrodesis L5-S1 con descompresión radicular bilateral. Todos los casos fueron estudiados en el preoperatorio con Rx, TC e IRM. El seguimiento promedio fue de 2.7 años. En los 3 casos se logró un buen control del dolor y de los síntomas neurológicos. La fusión se constató con radiografías simples en el control alejado. Conclusión: En todos los casos se logró un buen resultado clínico e imagenológico con una artrodesis sólida, realizada en un solo tiempo quirúrgico por abordaje posterior.

Objective: To report our surgical results treating three patients with traumatic L5-S1 spondylolisthesis, an infrequent lesion of which only a few isolated cases have been published. Materials and Methods: We reviewed the charts of three patients who underwent surgery from 2010-2015. Case 1 was a 30-year-old man who had fallen off a horse and in whom grade II lytic anterolisthesis was diagnosed, for which L4-S2 fusion with a L5-S1 TLIF was successfully performed. Case 2 was a 38-year-old man with severe low back pain after a car accident. Grade II anterolisthesis was diagnosed secondary to bilateral fractures of S1 facets, for which L5-S1 fusion was done. Case 3 was a 12-year-old child with low back and leg pain after a wall collapsed on top of him, who was diagnosed with anterolisthesis and bilateral facet dislocation. In this patient, L5-S1 fusion and realignment was performed. All patients were studied with full spine x-rays, CT scans and MRI. Average follow-up was 2.7 years. Pain was controlled and neurological deficits improved over the duration of long-term follow-up. X-rays revealed successful fusion in all cases.Conclusions: In our three cases, we achieved excellent clinical and radiological results with solid fusion, performed during a single surgical procedure.

Assuntos

RESUMO

La espondilolistesis traumática del axis representa un 5% de las fracturas cervicales y es definida por una fractura de la pars interarticularis de la segunda vértebra cervical. El mecanismo de esta fractura, en general, implica fuerzas de hiperextensión. Los aspectos más importantes relacionados con el pronóstico y tratamiento son el compromiso discal C2-C3, el compromiso neurológico y la presencia de luxación facetaria. En relación con los tratamientos conservador o quirúrgico en patrones no desplazados, la cirugía podría determinar una recuperación precoz. Por otro lado, se han descrito buenos resultados con el uso del halo chaleco. Se presenta un caso de espondilolistesis traumática del axis tratado con osteosíntesis directa a través de un abordaje posterior en un paciente que rechazó el tratamiento conservador.

Traumatic spondylolisthesis of the axis accounts for 5% of all cervical spine fractures and is defined as a pars interarticularis fracture in the second cervical vertebra. Its mechanism usually involves hyperextension forces. The most important aspects related to prognosis and treatment are C2-C3 disk injury, neurological involvement, facetary dislocation and displacement. As regards the conservative or surgical management in non-displaced patterns, surgical management could result in an early recovery; however, there are good results with halo vest immobilization. We present a case with C2 direct crew osteosynthesis through a posterior approach in a patient who refused conservative treatment.

Assuntos