RESUMO

The rupture of the Fundão dam is considered the largest mining failure in history, which had a particularly detrimental impact on fish populations, as the mud from the ore tailings significantly altered the water quality and habitat of Doce River basin. This study aimed to assess the trophic structure of fish communities in areas impacted and not impacted by the dam rupture in the Doce River basin. To evaluate the food web structure, community-wide trophic niche, and trophic positions of fish, stable isotopes of carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) were utilized across ten sites (seven impacted and three control). In general, fish appeared to assimilate resources such as invertebrates, algae, and periphyton, although the importance of each resource varied among sites. The site closest to the dam rupture exhibited a more simplified trophic structure compared to the control sites and those nearer the river mouth. In this site, most fish species occupied a similar trophic position. Trophic niches also exhibited the greatest dissimilarity between the site closest to the dam failure and those farther away from it, with an expansion of trophic niche breadth observed with an increase in the distance from the dam rupture. Our study provided valuable insights into the trophic structure of fish communities within the Doce River basin, shedding light on the trophic ecology of the 59 fish species investigated. We also emphasize the importance of our study for future assessments of ore tailings dam failure disasters and evaluating the effectiveness of mitigation measures for Doce River basin recovery.

Assuntos

RESUMO

The Doce River basin is located in the Brazilian states of Minas Gerais (MG) and Espírito Santo (ES). Anthropogenic expansion throughout the twentieth century heavily modified the bioecological configuration of the region, which was worsened in November 2015 by the collapse of the Fundão tailing dam in Mariana municipality (MG). Local ichthyofauna suffered a loss of environmental quality, which served as an alert to the possible decline of native species and transformation of fish assemblages. Through a systematic literature review, the present study aimed to investigate the recovery stage of fish assemblage after the disaster. To accomplish this, we selected 14 documents reporting species lists and fish distributions in the area principally affected by the disaster. Data collected about fish assemblage (presence/absence) were spatially (upper, middle, and lower sections) and temporally (pre- and post-disaster) arranged, followed by non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) analysis to assess similarity. We applied the Analysis of Similarities (ANOSIM) non-parametric test to confirm statistically significant differences between groups. We complemented the study by searching for the main bioecological characteristics of the most frequent species raised among the selected documents. NMDS showed differences in the similarity of fish assemblages among the three spatial sections, as confirmed by ANOSIM (p < 0.05), but no differences for the temporal component were observed. Nevertheless, we detected a trend based on continental fish assemblage transformation, as determined by the presence of many non-native species in the post-disaster period, suggesting the better resilience of these species over that of native species. The missing of many native species previously easily collected, mainly from the families Characidae, Loricariidae, and Trichomycteridae, suggested the system moving toward a new condition, probably worsened than the previous one. The ichthyofauna of the estuarine environment, on the contrary, seems to have recovered faster than ichthyofauna from the continental environment.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Identifying reliable biological indicators is fundamental to efficiently assess human impacts on biodiversity and to monitor the outcomes of management actions. This study investigates whether body condition is an appropriate indicator of putative effects from iron ore mining tailings on marine fishes, focusing on the world's largest mining disaster - known as the Mariana disaster, in Brazil. Eight species were used to test the hypothesis that individuals inhabiting an area severely impacted by tailings have reduced body condition in comparison to those in control areas near (<60 km) and distant (>120 km) from the impact site. Contrary to our prediction, no significant difference in condition was detected between the impacted area and both near and distant controls in seven of the eight species. The results indicate that body condition, as measured by the scaled mass index, has limited applicability as indicator of impact from mining pollution on the fishes analysed. Hypotheses that could explain our findings are proposed, including nutrient provisioning from continental drainage that could indirectly influence fish condition and compensate for the deleterious effects of mining pollution.

Assuntos

RESUMO

After Fundão Dam failure in 2015, most of Gualaxo do Norte River in Doce River Basin in Brazil became silted by iron mining tailings consisting mainly of fine-grained quartz, hematite, and goethite. Previous work pointed to the possibility of reductive dissolution of iron and manganese from tailings, leading to mobilization of iron, manganese and trace elements. Several microorganisms were shown to reduce Fe(III) to Fe(II) and Mn(III, IV) to Mn(II) "in vitro", but their roles in mobilization of Fe and trace elements from freshwater sediments are poorly understood. In this work, bottom sediments and water collected in Gualaxo do Norte River were used to build anoxic microcosms amended with acetate, glucose or yeast extract, in order to access if heterotrophic microorganisms, either fermenters or dissimilatory Fe reducers, could reduce Fe(III) from minerals in the sediments to soluble Fe(II), releasing trace elements. The Fe(II) concentrations were measured over time, and trace elements concentrations were evaluated at the end of the experiment. In addition, minerals and biopolymers in bottom sediments were quantified. Results showed that organic substrates, notably glucose, fuelled microbial reduction of iron minerals and release of Fe(II), Mn, Ba, Al and/or Zn from sediments. In general, higher concentrations of organic substrates elicited mobilization of larger amounts of Fe(II) and trace elements from sediments. The results point to the possibility of mobilization of huge amounts of iron and trace elements from sediments to water if excess biodegradable organic matter is released in rivers affected by iron mine tailings.

Assuntos

RESUMO

The Fundão dam failure, the worst environmental disaster in Brazilian history, launched 50 million m3 of iron ore tailings mud through the Doce River, reaching the Atlantic Ocean. Generally, mine tailings increase the sediment inflow, leading to mud burial of epibenthic macrofauna, and the raise of metal(oid)s concentration causing macrofauna long-term changes. After almost four years, tailings mud was still spreading on the Doce River Shelf, while impacts on marine macrofauna were still unknown. Herein, the IMS index (a tracer of Fundão dam tailings mud), sediment variables, organic pollutants, and metal(oid)s were integrated to uncover the drives of macrofauna structure from Costas da Algas to Abrolhos bank MPAs. Tailings mud was present only in Doce River Mouth and Degredo, organic pollutants and metal(oid)s above safety levels were concentrated in those same areas. Tailings mud (IMS index) drastically reduced species richness and diversity, favoring the abundance of opportunistic species. Mud, IMS index and Al, Ba, and V, metal(oid)s linked to dam failure, structured macrofauna composition in this impacted area, dominated by resistant groups as Nuculidae, Spionidae, and Magelonidae. Conversely, an opposite pattern was found for further and deeper sites with high CaCO3 content and total nitrogen that also showed large grain size, in areas known to harbour biogenic structures, sustaining a macrofauna composition distinct from the impacted areas, dominated by Syllidae and Crassatellidae, sensitives to impacts. Macrofauna composition was most structured by sediment variables, followed by the intersection between metal(oid)s-IMS and Mud, both gradients acting almost entirely on a broad spatial scale. Benthic macrofauna at the Doce River Shelf is still impacted by Fundão dam tailings mud, even after almost four years of the disaster, and may continue to, since the influx of tailings does not stop, and sediment resuspension is a recurrent source for those impacts.

Assuntos

RESUMO

The rupture of the Fundão mining dam (Doce river basin, Brazil) caused a wide range of negative impacts. Yet, assemblage-level implications to estuarine and coastal fishes remain unclear, partly due to the lack of pre-disaster information. Based on monthly otter trawl surveys, we analyzed spatial and seasonal variability in univariate (total biomass, biomass of species vulnerable to exploitation, rarefied richness and evenness) and multivariate (species composition and trophic composition) indicators of fish biodiversity in the Doce river delta, eastern Brazil. We determined the independent and interactive effects of environmental, seasonal and spatial variables on species composition to test whether environmental alterations provoked by mine tailings could affect assemblage's organization. Most indicators present idiosyncratic spatiotemporal patterns, suggesting they have complementary roles in revealing changes in fish biodiversity. Environmental variables, including those affected by the Fundão dam collapse such as turbidity, dissolved oxygen and pH, were much more important than seasonal and spatial predictors in explaining the variation in fish species composition. These findings highlight the potential from mine tailings to disrupt local ichthyofauna and indicate a preponderant role of environmental conditions in assemblage structuring. Given the lack of data prior to rupture, our results may be used as a baseline against which to assess temporal trends in fish biodiversity relative to changes detected in less disturbed estuarine and coastal assemblages.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Iron (Fe) oxyhydroxides provide many functions in soils, mainly owing to their large surface area and high surface charge density. The reactivity of Fe oxyhydroxides is function of their mineralogical characteristics (e.g., crystallinity degree and crystal size). Detailed studies of these features are essential for predicting the stability and reactivity of these minerals within soil and sediments. The present study aimed to evaluate geochemical changes in Fe-rich tailings after the world's largest mining disaster in SE Brazil (in 2015) and to predict the potential environmental implications for the estuary. The mineralogical characteristics of the tailings were studied at three different times (2015, 2107, and 2019) to assess how an active redox environment affects Fe oxyhydroxides and to estimate the time frame within which significant changes occur. The study findings indicate a large decrease in the Fe oxyhydroxides crystallinity, which were initially composed (93%) of highly crystalline Fe oxyhydroxides (i.e., goethite and hematite) and 6.7% of poorly crystalline Fe oxyhydroxides (i.e., lepidocrocite and ferrihydrite). Within 4 years the mineralogical features of Fe oxyhydroxides had shifted, and in 2019 poorly crystalline Fe oxyhydroxides represented 47% of the Fe forms. Scanning electron microscope micrographs and the mean crystal size evidenced a decrease in particle size from 109 nm to 49 nm for goethite in the d111 direction. The changes in mean crystal size increased the reactivity of Fe oxyhydroxides, resulting in a greater number of interactions with cationic and anionic species. The decreased crystallinity and increased reactivity led to the compounds being more susceptible to reductive dissolution. Overall, the findings show that the decrease in crystallinity along with higher susceptibility to reductive dissolution of Fe oxyhydroxides can affect the fate of environmentally detrimental elements (e.g., phosphorus and trace metals) thereby increasing the concentration of these pollutants in estuarine soils and waters.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Research has shown the effort to develop conceptual models that relate anthropic stressors to changes in aquatic environment state. Several of these models come from the structure Drivers, Pressures, State, Impact and Response (DPSIR), which has been used since the 1990s. However, there is a lack of conceptual models that consider in its structure the connection between the damages caused in the aquatic environment and technological disasters. This research develops a general conceptual model based on the DPSIR structure incorporating technological disasters. Based on the general conceptual model guidelines and the methodological procedure associated with it, a model was developed to assess the Lower Doce River waters' state, by considering Fundão's iron-ore dam failure scenario, which took place in November 2015, in the municipality of Mariana, state of Minas Gerais, Brazil. The relevant aspects of this adaptation of the DPSIR structure were: I) it considers the combined effect of drivers and pressures that already existed in the study area with those originated from the technological disaster; and II) the causal relationships among elements of the model were explicited through a systemic conceptual map, allowing a more holistic and integrated view of the problem. The application of the conceptual model to Doce River's scenario before the disaster allowed us to verify that a set of environmental pressures was already acting in a way to stress it, making the river vulnerable. For the post-disaster scenario, it was possible to determine that the already existing vulnerability condition, caused by urbanization, agriculture1 and mining, had been intensified by adding new pressures due to the tailings dam failure.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Temporal and spatial variabilities in concentrations of metals (Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, Hg, Mn, Pb and Zn) and metalloid (As) associated with the Fundão dam tailings were evaluated in water, sediment and biota from freshwater (tributary, river, lakes and lagoons), marine and coastal (mangroves and beaches) ecosystems affected by the Mariana dam disaster (southeastern Brazil). In freshwater shrimps and fishes, temporal increases in the concentrations of most elements analyzed were observed. This finding was clearly associated with temporal increases in the concentrations of As and metals observed in both water and sediment. In turn, freshwater plankton showed only a temporal increase in Hg concentration, which was also associated with an increased concentration of this metal in the abiotic matrices. In marine fishes, temporal increases were only observed for Cu, Fe and Pb concentrations. Also, temporal increase was observed for Fe concentration in marine plankton (phytoplankton and zooplankton) and shrimps. Marine phytoplankton also showed a temporal increase in Hg concentration. All these findings were clearly associated with temporal increases in the concentrations of these metals in marine sediments. Mangrove crabs showed temporal increases in Hg and Cd, which were associated with temporal increases in water Hg and sediment Cd concentrations, respectively. In turn, beach crabs displayed temporal increases in Mn and Zn, which were associated with temporal increases in the concentrations of these metals in sediments, especially for Mn. In summary, all environmental matrices evaluated in the present study were shown to be contaminated with metals and metalloid associated with the Fundão dam tailings. Additionally, findings reported in the present study relative to the spatial variabilities observed in the whole aquatic area affected by the Fundão dam failure clearly reinforce the need of incorporating biological diversity in monitoring programs aiming to assess environmental health of aquatic systems, considering that patterns of metals and metalloid contamination levels may vary among taxa.

Assuntos

RESUMO

The rupture of the Fundão dam (Mariana, MG, southeast Brazil) released a huge flood of mine tailings to Doce river basin and its adjacent coastal area, in November 2015. This catastrophic event exposed aquatic communities to metal contamination related to mine tailings, but its biological effects are still poorly understood. This study investigates how biochemical response related to metal exposure vary between locations and seasons during the years of 2018-2020, in planktonic communities (micro and mesoplankton). Marine microplankton collected in sectors in front and south of the Doce river mouth presented the highest lipid peroxidation (LPO) and induction of metallothioneins (MT). Mesoplankton collected in sectors in front and north of the Doce river mouth presented highest LPO, while MT in this size class did not respond to a clear spatial pattern. Our results showed that metals affected biomarkers in a non-linear pattern and highlighted the complex relationship between metals, biochemical parameters, and seasonality. The variation in biochemical biomarkers indicates physiological stress related to metals, once sectors contaminated by metals, especially Fe, Mn and Cd, presented stronger biochemical responses. Comparison of metal levels with bioaccumulation data collected before the impact indicates Fe, Cd, Cr and Cu more than 2-fold higher after disaster in sectors closer to the river. Literature showed that these sectors present zooplanktonic assemblages with lower biomass and biodiversity, suggesting that the opportunistic species that thrives in the area are also under biochemical stress, but possibly relies on repair or defense mechanisms. The physiological stress detected by this study is possibly related to the mine tailings, considering the metals that stood out and the proximity with the Doce river mouth. This suggests that the impacts related to the failure of Fundão dam are still affecting the marine planktonic community even three to four years after the environmental disaster.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Mining dam failures have increased worldwide since the 1980s. Two large mining dam failures occurred recently in Mariana and Brumadinho, both in the state of Minas Gerais, Brazil. We hypothesize that there were significant differences in legal post-disaster decisions. The aim of this article is to understand the similarities and differences of post-disaster actions and controversies in Mariana and Brumadinho. We reviewed 686 news reports about court decisions and settlement agreements from the websites of state and federal courts and judicial institutions. After classifying the reports using an adapted protocol from a media health observatory, we conducted a thematic analysis. Our analysis suggests that there were significant differences in legal post-disaster decisions in the cases of Mariana and Brumadinho. In Mariana, there was privatization of post-disaster management, with the creation of the Renova Foundation, a mediated indemnity program, lack of access to information for those affected, and uncertainties in health and resettlement issues. In Brumadinho, there was faster implementation of the recovery and compensation measures, faster recognition of affected parties, and stronger participation of the population since the first hearings. Even though there were particularities in post-disaster management, the ultimate goal of the corporations responsible for the disasters was to protect their profits.

Assuntos

RESUMO

Based on the interdisciplinary concept of One Health, EcoHealth, and Planetary Health, this paper focuses on participatory knowledge-to-action approaches by relating one decade of environmental disasters in Brazil with the action of veterinary rescue teams, aiming to give support to future disaster preparedness. This paper will present the historic actions of teams rescuing animal that are victims of environmental disasters, in addition to addressing the need for contingency plans and response management in these types of events. The main events in Brazilian states where veterinary rescue teams participated were, chronologically, as follows: 2011 flood and landslide (Rio de Janeiro); 2012 flood (Acre, Minas Gerais, and Pará); 2015 dam break (Minas Gerais); 2017 flood (Minas Gerais) and forest fire (Minas Gerais and Goiás); 2019 dam break and evacuation (Minas Gerais) and flood (Bahia); 2020 flood (Espírito Santo and Minas Gerais) and forest fires (Mato Grosso and Mato Grosso do Sul). The Brazilian disasters that had a large global repercussion were the ruptures of the ore dams in Marina (2015) and Brumadinho (2019), both in the State of Minas Gerais. The role of veterinarians in these events was recognized by the Federal Council of Veterinary Medicine (CFMV) after their performance in Mariana, Minas Gerais (2015), and in 2020, the CFMV approved the National Mass Disaster Contingency Plan Involving Animals. The work of veterinarians in interaction with other professionals in environmental disasters proved to be effective and necessary for the rescue of animals and for planning and giving support to disaster preparedness in the future.

Assuntos

RESUMO

The tailings spilled by the Fundão Dam rupture in the Doce River basin (Brazil) had a high pH, elevated sodium (Na) and ether amine, and low soil organic matter. With the aim of decreasing the toxic compounds, we established 2 remediation strategies: treatment 1, phytoremediation with tolerant native species of the Atlantic Forest cultivated on scraped sediment plus the incorporation of organic matter; and treatment 2, phytoremediation with native species plus superficial deposition of organic matter. The experimental site was compared with a degraded site that the dam tailings had reached and with a preserved site, a fragment of preserved Atlantic Forest. After 12 mo, plants showed an outstanding growth, especially after treatment 1 (~4 m), and the remediation procedures resulted in significant decreases in pH (from 8.0 to ~ 6.0), Na (from 154 to 22-35 mg/kg), electrical conductivity, and ether amine (from 6.0 to 0.5 mg/kg) in both treatments. By contrast, ammonium, a product of ether amine degradation, showed a significant increase in the experimental site, along with a significant increase in nitrate and improvement of soil microbial populations assessed by phospholipid fatty acid analysis. The treatments also improved soil fertility in the experimental site, as estimated by soil nutrients, cation exchange capacity, and soil aggregation. Based on the parameters analyzed, a principal component analysis showed that samples from the degraded site and the preserved site clustered in an opposite position and those from the experimental site clustered in an intermediate position but closer to the samples from the preserved site. Overall, our results demonstrated that the remediation procedures adopted were effective and resulted in rehabilitation of a riparian forest contaminated with dam tailings that included Na and ether amine. Environ Toxicol Chem 2021;40:2359-2373. © 2021 SETAC.

Assuntos

RESUMO

The Fundão dam was designed to store iron mine tailings in the region of Mariana, MG, Brazil. When it ruptured, the tailings overflowed. These tailings affected the soil due to the formation of a thick crust as a result of drying (compaction) and hindered the natural revegetation process. In this context, the use of organic fertilizers, including vermicompost, is method of reducing the physical limitations on root growth caused by soil properties and changing soil-metal interactions. For this reason, vermicompost was added to iron mine tailings, and its morphological and physiological effects on maize, millet and sorghum plants were studied. The experiment was conducted in a greenhouse using 6 dm3 pots. The plants were subjected to three treatments: mine tailings, mine tailings + vermicompost, and a reference soil. From the V3 stage onwards, biweekly growth, leaf gas exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence evaluations were performed. At the end of the experiment, dry biomass and metal, macro- and micronutrient contents were quantified, and the root morphology was evaluated. The tailings created physical limitations on root growth and had low nutrient content as well as high concentrations of chromium, iron and manganese. The addition of vermicompost favored increases in shoot and root dry biomass, increases in root length, volume, surface area and diameter, and the absorption of macro- and micronutrients, which was reflected in the growth of the studied species. In addition, vermicompost led to greater investment in thick and very thick roots, and in general, the plants showed no symptoms of metal toxicity. Considering the characteristics of the studied tailings, it can be concluded that vermicompost favors the growth of plant species and may be a viable method for beginning the recovery process in areas containing iron mine tailings.

Assuntos

RESUMO

The objective of this study was to evaluate the concentration of potentially toxic elements in Brachiaria decumbens, Stylosanthes guianensis, and Saccharum officinarum plants and soil samples in affected and unaffected areas by rupture of the Fundão dam, Brazil. Samples were collected in areas affected by residues from the Fundão dam (RAA1, RAA2, RAA3) and in an unaffected area (control). The material was analyzed for the composition of micronutrients and trace elements in soil and plants, as well as contamination factor (CF), accumulation factor, and translocation factor (TF). Overall, the results showed that soil and plant tissues had increased Fe, Mn, Cu, and Cr content and decreased Zn content in the affected areas, compared to the control. Leaves and roots of B. decumbens showed an increase in Fe content in affected areas, compared to the control, reaching a mean maximum value of 42 958 µg/g of roots of RAA2-collected plants. As a result, CF for Fe of B. decumbens was classified as very high and they presented low TF values. Furthermore, B. decumbens collected in affected areas showed an increase of Fe, Mn, Cu, and Cr in leaves, stems, and roots, whereas in Stylosanthes guianensis, there was an increase of Fe concentration in all tissues and Cr in leaves. Also, Saccharum officinarum showed the accumulation of Mn in the stem and Cu in leaves and stem. On the other hand, there was no contamination of plants by hazardous elements such as Pb, Cd, and As in the samples analyzed. In conclusion, increases in the content of Fe, Mn, Cu, and Cr were found in soil and several plant tissues of residue-affected areas, which could compromise plant growth and represent potential hazards arising from the biomagnification process in the food chain. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2020;16:596-607. © 2020 SETAC.

O objetivo deste estudo foi avaliar a concentração de elementos potencialmente tóxicos em plantas de Brachiaria decumbens, Stylosanthes guianensis e Saccharum officinarum e amostras de solos em áreas afetadas e não afetadas pelo rompimento da barragem de Fundão. As amostras foram coletadas em áreas afetadas por resíduos da barragem de Fundão (RAA1, RAA2, RAA3) e em uma área não afetada (controle). O material foi analisado quanto à composição de micronutrientes e elementos-traço no solo e plantas, além de fatores de contaminação (CF), bioacumulação e translocação (TF). No geral, os resultados mostraram que o solo e as plantas apresentaram maiores teores de Fe, Mn, Cu e Cr e menores teores de Zn nas áreas afetadas em comparação ao controle. Folhas e raízes de B. decumbens apresentaram aumento no teor de Fe nas áreas afetadas em relação ao controle, atingindo o valor máximo médio de 42.958 µg/g nas raízes de plantas coletadas em RAA2. Como resultado, CF para Fe de B. decumbens foi classificado como muito alto, mas com baixos valores de TF. Além disso, B. decumbens coletadas nas áreas afetadas apresentaram aumento de Fe, Mn, Cu e Cr nas folhas, caules e raízes, enquanto que em Stylosanthes guianensis houve aumento da concentração de Fe em todos as partes das plantas e Cr nas folhas. Saccharum officinarum também apresentou acúmulo de Mn no caule e Cu nas folhas e caule. Por outro lado, não há contaminação das plantas por elementos perigosos como Pb, Cd e As nas amostras analisadas. Concluindo, foram encontrados aumentos nos teores de Fe, Mn, Cu e Cr no solo e em vários tecidos vegetais, o que pode comprometer o crescimento das plantas e representar riscos potenciais decorrentes do processo de biomagnificação na cadeia alimentar. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2020;16:596-607.

Assuntos

RESUMO

In this work, samples of Fe mining tailings from the collapsed Fundão Dam, Brazil, which were retained by the Candonga hydroelectric power plant, were characterized by various techniques. Quartz, hematite, kaolinite, and goethite were identified as the main phases present. The composition, homogeneity, and relatively low (~1%) organic matter content indicate potential for usage of these tailings in civil constructions. The next step of this work is to investigate such applications. If their feasibility is confirmed, the goal is to use this material for construction in the areas affected by the Fundão Dam rupture. This use will lead to positive socio-environmental impacts in these regions, where tailings still need to be removed and damaged infrastructure needs to be repaired. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2020;16:636-642. © 2019 SETAC.

Neste trabalho, amostras do rejeito de mineração de ferro, proveniente do rompimento da barragem de Fundão e retidas pela usina hidroelétrica de Candonga, foram caracterizadas por diversas técnicas. Quartzo, hematita, caulinita e ghoetita foram identificadas como as principais fases presentes no rejeito. A composição, homogeneidade e teor de matéria orgânica relativamente baixo, cerca de 1%, indicam uso potencial deste material em construção civil. O próximo passo deste trabalho é investigar tais aplicações. Se a viabilidade for confirmada, o objetivo é utilizar esse material para obras nas áreas afetadas pelo rompimento da barragem de Fundão. Isso contribuirá para reduzir os impactos socioambientais nessas regiões, as quais ainda necessitam da remoção do rejeito e de reparos na infraestrutura danificada. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2020;16:636-642.

Assuntos

RESUMO

On November 2015, the Fundão Tailings Dam, located at Mariana municipality in Brazil, failed. Besides the deaths and injuries, economic losses, pollution and health problems associated to heavy metals in the water, Brazilian municipalities near the accident experienced an increase in the incidence of dengue. Since dengue fever is an insect-borne disease and the mosquito develops where there is stored water, there must be a relationship between the dam accident and the incidence of the disease. The purpose of this study is to test whether there is a causal relationship between the dam accident in Mariana and the number of dengue cases, number of hospitalizations due to dengue, and dengue outbreak in the municipalities affected by the accident. We find evidence that the accident had a positive and statistically significant impact on dengue indicators (for example, the probability of a dengue outbreak increased in 19%), what makes us call attention to another negative externality of tailings dam accidents.

Assuntos

RESUMO

In November 2015, the Fundão Dam collapsed releasing about 35 million m-3 of iron ore tailings into the environment, which covered approximately 15 km2 of floodplain soils. Four years later, there is still great concern and controversy regarding contamination by heavy metals in the affected areas. Thus, the present study sought to evaluate the heavy metal contents and its distribution in tailings and non-affected soils. Tailings samples were collected in the stretch between Bento Rodrigues and the Candonga hydroelectric plant, in addition to a sample inside the Fundão Dam. Non-affected soils and river sediments from the same region were also collected as a control group. The heavy metal contents in the tailings were lower than in non-affected samples from the same area, discarding the hypothesis of contamination by the tailings mud. The non-affected samples presented high levels of As, Ba, Co, Cr, Cu, Ni and Zn, with at least one sample exceeding the quality reference values (QRV's) established for Minas Gerais state, which indicated a scenario of pre-disaster contamination for the Doce River watershed. Most of the elements (As, Cr, Cu, Ni, V and Zn) were extracted in the residual fraction of the BCR sequential extraction, presenting low risk of release in nature. The health risk assessment for As estimated that all the non-affected soils and sediments from Gualaxo do Norte, Carmo and Doce rivers have carcinogenic risk higher than the acceptable value for children. From our results, it is more likely to conclude that the deposited tailings are not a time-bomb for heavy metals contamination in the region.

RESUMO

Resumo No dia 5 de novembro de 2015, o rompimento da barragem de rejeitos de Fundão em Mariana-MG (Brasil) de propriedade das mineradoras Samarco, Vale e BHP Billiton destruiu comunidades e contaminou o Rio Doce, sendo reconhecido como o maior desastre/crime sócio ambiental do Brasil. Nosso objetivo neste artigo é compreender os sentidos de comunidade construídos e acessados pelos atingidos dessas localidades anteriormente ao desastre e após o mesmo. Para tal, recorreremos a dados coletados durante diferentes contatos com o campo realizados pelas três autoras e que incluíram a realização de visitas aos territórios, entrevistas com atingidos e atingidas, observação participante (eventos, reuniões, outros), registro em diário de campo. Os resultados apontam que há uma constante busca por tentar recriar o sentimento de comunidade que se mostra principalmente na manutenção do vínculo com o espaço físico devastado e na tentativa de recriar o mesmo no espaço onde será feito o reassentamento.

Resumen El 5 de noviembre de 2015, la ruptura de la presa de relaves Fundão en Mariana-MG (Brasil), propiedad de las compañías mineras Samarco, Vale y BHP Billiton, destruyó comunidades y contaminó el Río Doce, siendo reconocido como el mayor desastre/crimen socioambiental en Brasil. Nuestro objetivo en este artículo es comprender los significados de la comunidad construida y accedida por los afectados en estos lugares antes y después del desastre. Con este fin, utilizaremos los datos recopilados durante los diferentes contactos con el campo llevados a cabo por las tres autoras, que incluyeron visitas a los territorios, entrevistas con los afectados y afectadas, observación participante (eventos, reuniones, otros) y registro en un diario de campo. Los resultados muestran que existe una búsqueda constante para tratar de recrear el sentimiento de comunidad que se muestra principalmente en el mantenimiento del vínculo con el espacio físico devastado y en el intento de recrearlo en el espacio donde se realizará el reasentamiento.

Abstract On November 5, 2015, the Fundão dam owned by the mining companies Samarco, Vale and BHP Billiton broke in Mariana/MG (Brazil), destroying communities and contaminating the Rio Doce, being recognized as the biggest socio-environmental catastrophe/crime in Brazil. Our goal in this article is to understand the senses of community built and accessed by those affected before and after the disaster. To this end, we used data collected during different field contacts made by the three authors, which included visits to the affected territories, interviews with those affected, participant observation (events, meetings and others), and recording in a field diary. The results indicate that there is a constant search to try to recreate the feeling of community, which is shown mainly in the maintenance of the bond with the devastated physical space and in the attempt to recreate it in the space where the resettlement will be done.

Assuntos

RESUMO

O presente estudo centra-se na ocorrência dos desastres socioambientais, que estão intimamente relacionados às decisões administrativas e à priorização de resultados econômico-financeiros feitas pelos tomadores de decisão das grandes empresas. O objetivo do artigo é analisar o comportamento dos deputados estaduais do Espírito Santo em um momento crítico, qual seja, o desastre da barragem de Mariana, provocado pela Samarco/Vale/BHP. Busca-se, especificamente, apresentar um panorama geral da produção legislativa, e observar de que maneira o comportamento destes parlamentares pode estar associado às doações de campanha realizadas pelo grupo empresarial causador do desastre. Foram analisadas as 25 proposições apresentadas pelos deputados acerca do caso em análise, entre os anos de 2015 e 2019. Os resultados encontrados sugerem relação entre comportamento legislativo e financiamento de campanha. Os políticos financiados buscaram, sobretudo, interromper as investigações e solicitar o retorno das atividades da Samarco.

This research focuses on the occurrence of socio-environmental disasters, which are closely related to administrative decisions and the prioritization of economic and financial results made by decision makers of large companies. The purpose of the paper is to analyze the behavior of state representatives of Espírito Santo in a critical moment, namely the Mariana dam disaster, caused by Samarco / Vale / BHP. Specifically, it seeks to present an overview of legislative production, and to observe how the behavior of these parliamentarians may be associated with campaign donations made by the business group that caused the disaster. We analyzed the 25 propositions presented by the deputies about the case under analysis, between 2015 and 2019. The results suggest a relationship between legislative behavior and campaign financing. The funded politicians sought, above all, to interrupt the investigations and to request the return of Samarco's activities.

El presente estudio se centra en la ocurrencia de desastres socioambientales, que están estrechamente relacionados con las decisiones administrativas y la priorización de los resultados económicos y financieros realizados por los tomadores de decisiones de las grandes empresas. El propósito del paper es analizar el comportamiento de los representantes estatales de Espírito Santo en un momento crítico, a saber, el desastre de la presa Mariana, causado por Samarco / Vale / BHP. Específicamente, busca presentar una visión general de la producción legislativa y observar cómo el comportamiento de estos parlamentarios puede estar asociado con las donaciones de campaña realizadas por el grupo empresarial que causó el desastre. Analizamos las 25 propuestas presentadas por los diputados sobre el caso bajo análisis, entre 2015 y 2019. Los resultados sugieren una relación entre el comportamiento legislativo y el financiamiento de campañas. Los políticos financiados buscaron, sobre todo, interrumpir las investigaciones y solicitar el regreso de las actividades de Samarco.

Cette étude se concentre sur la survenue de catastrophes socio-environnementales, étroitement liées aux décisions administratives et à la hiérarchisation des résultats économiques et financiers des décideurs des grandes entreprises. L'objectif de l'article est d'analyser le comportement des représentants de l'État d'Espírito Santo à un moment critique, à savoir la catastrophe du barrage de Mariana, causée par Samarco / Vale / BHP. Plus précisément, il cherche à présenter un aperçu de la production législative et à observer comment le comportement de ces parlementaires peut être associé aux dons de campagne effectués par le groupe d'entreprises qui a causé la catastrophe. Nous avons analysé les 25 propositions présentées par les députés sur le cas sous analyse, entre 2015 et 2019. Les résultats suggèrent une relation entre le comportement législatif et le financement des campagnes. Les politiciens financés ont surtout cherché à interrompre les enquêtes et à demander le retour des activités de Samarco.