RESUMO
The analysis of zoonotic disease risk requires the consideration of both human and animal geo-referenced disease incidence data. Here we show an application of joint Bayesian analyses to the study of echinococcosis granulosus (EG) in the province of Rio Negro, Argentina. We focus on merging passive and active surveillance data sources of animal and human EG cases using joint Bayesian spatial and spatio-temporal models. While similar spatial clustering and temporal trending was apparent, there appears to be limited lagged dependence between animal and human outcomes. Beyond the data quality issues relating to missingness at different times, we were able to identify relations between dog and human data and the highest 'at risk' areas for echinococcosis within the province.
Assuntos
Doenças do Cão/epidemiologia , Equinococose/epidemiologia , Vigilância em Saúde Pública/métodos , Zoonoses/epidemiologia , Adolescente , Animais , Argentina/epidemiologia , Teorema de Bayes , Criança , Cães , Echinococcus granulosus , Humanos , Modelos BiológicosRESUMO
[ABSTRACT]. Objective. To compare the performance of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) tests for diagnosing Echinococcus granulosus in dog feces among national reference laboratories in Argentina, Chile, Peru, and Uruguay. Methods. National laboratories affiliated with the Ministry of Health/Agriculture of each country exchanged panels of 10 positive/negative samples obtained from their regular national surveillance programs in November 2015 – November 2016. All laboratories applied PCR; two also applied ELISA techniques. Sensitivity and specificity were determined for each laboratory and concordance of results among the laboratories was evaluated by Cohen Kappa coefficient. Results. Poor concordance (3 of 10 paired comparisons had values of Kappa > 0.4), low sensitivity and specificity across all laboratories, and poor performance of both techniques in detecting E. granulosus in canine feces was demonstrated in this study. An ex-post comparison of the laboratories’ test protocols showed substantial heterogeneity that could partially explain poor concordance of results. Conclusion. The results underscore the heterogeneity of canine echinococcosis diagnosis across the region and indicate possible sources of variability. Efforts to standardize canine echinococcosis testing must be included in the plan of action for the Regional Initiative for the Control of Cystic Echinococcosis. Future comparisons with fecal samples of known parasite load are needed.
[RESUMEN]. Objetivo. Comparar el rendimiento de los ensayos de la reacción en cadena de la polimerasa y el enzimoinmunoanálisis de adsorción en fase sólida (o ELISA, por su sigla en inglés) para diagnosticar Echinococcus granulosus en heces caninas en los laboratorios de referencia nacionales de Argentina, Chile, Perú y Uruguay. Métodos. Los laboratorios nacionales, afiliados a los ministerios de salud y agricultura y ganadería de cada país, intercambiaron paneles de diez muestras positivas y negativas obtenidas de sus respectivos programas nacionales de vigilancia desde el mes de noviembre del año 2015 hasta el mismo mes del año siguiente. Todos los laboratorios emplearon la reacción en cadena de la polimerasa y dos emplearon también técnicas de ensayo inmunoenzimático (ELISA). Se determinó la sensibilidad y la especificidad de cada laboratorio y se evaluó la concordancia entre los resultados de los laboratorios mediante el coeficiente kappa de Cohen. Resultados. Este estudio descubrió una escasa concordancia (3 de 10 comparaciones de pares obtuvieron valores de kappa > 0,4), una sensibilidad y especificidad bajas en todos los laboratorios y un rendimiento deficiente de ambas técnicas de diagnóstico de Echinococcus granulosus en heces caninas. La comparación ex post de los protocolos de ensayo de los laboratorios mostró una heterogeneidad sustancial que podría explicar parcialmente la escasa concordancia de los resultados. Conclusiones. Los resultados subrayan la heterogeneidad del diagnóstico de equinococosis canina en toda la región e indican posibles fuentes de esta variabilidad. Deben incluirse medidas para estandarizar la prueba de equinococosis canina en el plan de acción de la Iniciativa Sudamericana para el Control de la Equinococosis Quística. En el futuro serán necesarias comparaciones adicionales con muestras fecales con una carga de parásitos conocida.
[RESUMO]. Objetivo. Comparar o desempenho dos métodos de reação em cadeia da polimerase (PCR) e ensaio imunoenzimático (ELISA) no diagnóstico de infecção pelo Echinococcus granulosus em fezes de cães entre laboratórios de referência nacional na Argentina, Chile, Peru e Uruguai. Métodos. Laboratórios nacionais conveniados ao Ministério da Saúde/Agricultura de cada país participante intercambiaram grupos de 10 amostras positivas/negativas coletadas rotineiramente pelos programas nacionais de vigilância no período de novembro de 2015 a novembro de 2016. Todos os laboratórios empregaram o método de PCR e dois empregaram também o método de ELISA. A sensibilidade e a especificidade dos métodos foram determinadas em cada laboratório, e a concordância dos resultados entre os laboratórios participantes foi avaliada com o coeficiente kappa de Cohen. Resultados. Observou-se fraca concordância (3 de 10 comparações pareadas com kappa >0,4), baixa sensibilidade e especificidade e fraco desempenho de ambos os métodos na identificação do E. granulosus em amostras fecais de cães nos laboratórios participantes do estudo. Uma comparação retroativa revelou considerável heterogeneidade dos protocolos de análise laboratorial, o que poderia em parte explicar a fraca concordância entre os resultados. Conclusões. Os resultados deste estudo apontam para a falta de uniformidade no diagnóstico de equinococose canina em toda a Região e indicam possíveis causas para variabilidade. A padronização da análise laboratorial da equinococose canina deve constar do plano de ação para a Iniciativa Regional para Controle da Hidatidose. Outras comparações de amostras fecais de parasitas conhecidos devem ser realizadas.
Assuntos
Equinococose , Doenças do Cão , Ensaio de Proficiência Laboratorial , América do Sul , Equinococose , Doenças do Cão , Ensaio de Proficiência Laboratorial , América do Sul , Equinococose , Doenças do Cão , Ensaio de Proficiência Laboratorial , América do SulRESUMO
The large number of activities contributing to zoonoses surveillance and control capability, on both human and animal domains, and their likely heterogeneous implementation across administrative units make assessment and comparisons of capability performance between such units a complex task. Such comparisons are important to identify gaps in capability development, which could lead to clusters of vulnerable areas, and to rank and subsequently prioritize resource allocation toward the least capable administrative units. Area-level preparedness is a multidimensional entity and, to the best of our knowledge, there is no consensus on a single comprehensive indicator, or combination of indicators, in a summary metric. We use Bayesian spatial factor analysis models to jointly estimate and rank disease control and surveillance capabilities against visceral leishmaniasis (VL) at the municipality level in Brazil. The latent level of joint capability is informed by four variables at each municipality, three reflecting efforts to monitor and control the disease in humans, and one variable informing surveillance capability on the reservoir, the domestic dog. Because of the large volume of missing data, we applied imputation techniques to allow production of comprehensive rankings. We were able to show the application of these models to this sparse dataset and present a ranked list of municipalities based on their overall VL capability. We discuss improvements to our models, and additional applications.
Assuntos
Antiprotozoários/uso terapêutico , Leishmaniose Visceral/epidemiologia , Leishmaniose Visceral/prevenção & controle , Animais , Teorema de Bayes , Brasil/epidemiologia , Humanos , Modelos Biológicos , Vigilância da PopulaçãoRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: To compare the performance of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) tests for diagnosing Echinococcus granulosus in dog feces among national reference laboratories in Argentina, Chile, Peru, and Uruguay. METHODS: National laboratories affiliated with the Ministry of Health/Agriculture of each country exchanged panels of 10 positive/negative samples obtained from their regular national surveillance programs in November 2015 - November 2016. All laboratories applied PCR; two also applied ELISA techniques. Sensitivity and specificity were determined for each laboratory and concordance of results among the laboratories was evaluated by Cohen Kappa coefficient. RESULTS: Poor concordance (3 of 10 paired comparisons had values of Kappa > 0.4), low sensitivity and specificity across all laboratories, and poor performance of both techniques in detecting E. granulosus in canine feces was demonstrated in this study. An ex-post comparison of the laboratories' test protocols showed substantial heterogeneity that could partially explain poor concordance of results. CONCLUSION: The results underscore the heterogeneity of canine echinococcosis diagnosis across the region and indicate possible sources of variability. Efforts to standardize canine echinococcosis testing must be included in the plan of action for the Regional Initiative for the Control of Cystic Echinococcosis. Future comparisons with fecal samples of known parasite load are needed.
RESUMO
Through national efforts and regional cooperation under the umbrella of the Regional Program for the Elimination of Rabies, dog and human rabies have decreased significantly in Latin America and Caribbean (LAC) countries over the last three decades. To achieve this decline, LAC countries had to develop national plans, and consolidate capabilities such as regular mass dog vaccination, opportune post-exposure prophylaxis and sensitive surveillance. This paper presents longitudinal data for 21 LAC countries on dog vaccination, PEP and rabies surveillance collected from the biannual regional meeting for rabies directors from 1998-2014 and from the Regional Epidemiologic Surveillance System for Rabies (SIRVERA). Differences in human and dog rabies incidence rates and dog vaccination rates were shown between low, middle and high-income countries. At the peak, over 50 million dogs were vaccinated annually in national campaigns in the countries represented. The reported number of animal exposures remained fairly stable during the study period with an incidence rate ranging from 123 to 191 reported exposures per 100,000 people. On average, over 2 million doses of human vaccine were applied annually. In the most recent survey, only 37% of countries reported that they had sufficient financial resources to meet the program objectives. The data show a sufficient and sustained effort of the LAC countries in the area of dog vaccination and provide understanding of the baseline effort required to reduce dog-mediated rabies incidence.
Assuntos
Doenças do Cão/prevenção & controle , Vacina Antirrábica , Raiva/epidemiologia , Animais , Região do Caribe/epidemiologia , Doenças do Cão/epidemiologia , Doenças do Cão/virologia , Cães , Humanos , América Latina/epidemiologia , Vacinação em Massa/veterinária , Profilaxia Pós-Exposição , Raiva/transmissão , Raiva/veterinária , Raiva/virologia , Vacina Antirrábica/administração & dosagem , Vacina Antirrábica/economia , Inquéritos e Questionários , Vacinação/economia , Vacinação/estatística & dados numéricos , Vacinação/veterináriaRESUMO
Cystic echinococcosis (CE) or hydatidosis, a parasitic zoonosis caused by a cestode of the family Taeniidae, species Echinococcus granulosus, is endemic in Argentina, Chile, Peru, Uruguay, and southern Brazil. This report presents CE figures for these five countries in 2009 – 2014 and proposes indicators to measure national control programs. Nearly 5 000 new CE cases were diagnosed annually in the five countries during the study period. The average case fatality rate was 2.9%, which suggests that CE led to approximately 880 deaths in these countries during the 6-year period. CE cases that required secondary or tertiary health care had average hospital stays of 10.6 days, causing a significant burden to health systems. The proportion of new cases (15%) in children less than 15 years of age suggests ongoing transmission. Despite figures showing that CE is not under control in South America, the long-standing implementation of national and local control programs in three of the five countries has achieved reductions in some of the indicators. The Regional Initiative for the Control of CE, which includes the five countries and provides a framework for networking and collaboration, must intensify its efforts.
La equinococosis quística o hidatidosis, zoonosis parasitaria causada por un cestodo de la especie Echinococcus granulosus, familia Taeniidae, es endémica en Argentina, Chile, Perú, Uruguay y el sur del Brasil. En este informe se presentan datos sobre la equinococosis quística registrados en estos cinco países entre los años 2009 y 2014, y se proponen indicadores para medir el desempeño de los programas nacionales de control. Durante el período de estudio, en los cinco países se diagnosticaron casi 5 000 casos nuevos por año. La tasa de letalidad promedio fue del 2,9 %, lo que indica que la equinococosis quística causó aproximadamente 880 defunciones en estos países en el período de 6 años estudiado. Los casos que debieron recibir atención de salud secundaria o terciaria tuvieron una estadía hospitalaria promedio de 10,6 días, lo que ha generado una carga significativa para los sistemas de salud. La proporción de casos nuevos de niños menores de 15 años (15 %) indica que la transmisión no se ha interrumpido. A pesar de que los datos muestran que la enfermedad no está controlada en América del Sur, tres de los cinco países disponen de programas nacionales y locales de control desde hace muchos años, los que han logrado reducir algunos de los indicadores. Es preciso que la Iniciativa Sudamericana para el Control de la Equinococosis Quística, que incluye a los cinco países y contribuye con un marco para la formación de redes y la colaboración, redoble sus esfuerzos para lograr el control de la enfermedad.
A equinococose cística ou hidatidose, zoonose parasitária causada por um céstodo da família Taeniidae e espécie Echinococcus granulosus, é endêmica na Argentina, Chile, Peru, Uruguai e no sul do Brasil. Neste artigo são apresentadas as estimativas da hidatidose nos cinco países de 2009 a 2014 e propostos indicadores para avaliar os programas nacionais de controle. Cerca de 5 mil casos novos de hidatidose foram diagnosticados por ano nos cinco países no período de estudo. A taxa de letalidade média foi de 2,9%, o que indica que esta doença causou aproximadamente 880 mortes nestes países no período de 6 anos. Nos casos de hidatidose que precisaram de atenção de saúde secundária ou terciária, a duração média da internação hospitalar foi de 10,6 dias, representando uma sobrecarga considerável aos sistemas de saúde. O percentual de novos casos (15%) em indivíduos menores de 15 anos de idade indica transmissão contínua. Apesar de as estimativas mostrarem que a hidatidose não está controlada na América do Sul, a execução permanente de programas municipais e nacionais de controle em três dos cinco países tem redundado na redução de alguns dos indicadores. A Iniciativa Regional para Controle da Hidatidose, que integra os cinco países em uma estrutura para trabalho em conjunto e colaboração, deve redobrar os seus esforços.
Assuntos
Zoonoses , Equinococose , Echinococcus granulosus , América do Sul , ZoonosesRESUMO
The direct fluorescent antibody test (DFA), is performed in all rabies reference laboratories across Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC). Despite DFA being a critical capacity in the control of rabies, there is not a standardized protocol in the region. We describe the results of the first inter-laboratory proficiency exercise of national rabies laboratories in LAC countries as part of the regional efforts towards dog-maintained rabies elimination in the American region. Twenty three laboratories affiliated to the Ministries of Health and Ministries of Agriculture participated in this exercise. In addition, the laboratories completed an online questionnaire to assess laboratory practices. Answers to the online questionnaire indicated large variability in the laboratories throughput, equipment used, protocols availability, quality control standards and biosafety requirements. Our results will inform actions to improve and harmonize laboratory rabies capacities across LAC in support for the regional efforts towards elimination of dog-maintained rabies.
Assuntos
Doenças do Cão/diagnóstico , Ensaio de Proficiência Laboratorial/normas , Saúde Pública , Vírus da Raiva/imunologia , Raiva/diagnóstico , Animais , Encéfalo/virologia , Região do Caribe , Erradicação de Doenças , Doenças do Cão/prevenção & controle , Doenças do Cão/virologia , Cães , Técnica Direta de Fluorescência para Anticorpo , Humanos , Cooperação Internacional , Internet , América Latina , Controle de Qualidade , Raiva/prevenção & controle , Raiva/virologia , Vírus da Raiva/isolamento & purificação , Sensibilidade e Especificidade , Inquéritos e QuestionáriosRESUMO
BACKGROUND: In recent years, global public health security has been threatened by zoonotic disease emergence as exemplified by outbreaks of H5N1 and H1N1 influenza, SARS, and most recently Ebola and Zika. Additionally, endemic zoonoses, such as rabies, burden countries year after year, placing demands on limited finances and personnel. To survey the baseline status of the emerging and endemic zoonoses programmes of the Latin American and the Caribbean (LAC) countries, the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) conducted a survey of priority emerging and endemic zoonoses, countries´ prioritization criteria and methodologies, and suggestions to strengthen countries capacities and regional approaches to zoonoses control. METHODS: A fillable online questionnaire was sent to the zoonoses programme managers of the Ministries of Health (MOH) and Ministries of Agriculture (MAg) of 33 LAC countries from January to April of 2015. The questionnaire comprised 36 single, multiple choice and open-ended questions to inform the objectives of the survey. A descriptive exploratory analysis was completed. RESULTS: Fifty-four ministries (26 MOH, 25 MAg, and 3 combined responses) in 31 LAC countries responded to the survey. Within the ministries, 22 (85%) MOH, 5 (20%) MAg, and 2 (67%) combined entities indicated they had specialized zoonoses units. For endemic zoonoses, 32 of 54 ministries responded that they conduct formal prioritization exercises, most of them annually (69%). The three priority endemic zoonoses for the MOHs were leptospirosis, rabies, and brucellosis while the three priorities for the MAgs were brucellosis, rabies, and tuberculosis. Diagnosis for rabies and leptospirosis were cited as the capacities most in need of development. The most needed cross-cutting capacity was coordination between stakeholders. For emerging zoonoses, 28 ministries performed formal prioritization exercises. The top prioritization criteria were probability of introduction into the country and impact. The three priority emerging zoonoses for the MOHs were Ebola viral disease, avian influenza, and Chikungunya while for the MAgs were avian influenza, bovine spongiform encephalopathy and West Nile virus disease. Surveillance for avian influenza and Ebola, and diagnosis for BSE were quoted as the capacities most needed. For all zoonoses, the majority of respondents (69%) ranked their relationship with the other Ministry as productive or very productive, and 31% minimally productive. Many countries requested a formal regional network, better regional communication and collaboration, and integrated surveillance. CONCLUSIONS: The survey is the first comprehensive effort to date to inform the status of zoonoses programmes in LAC. The information collected here will be used to develop a regional strategy for zoonoses (both endemic and emerging), increase efforts, advocacy, and promote prompt identification and management of EIDs and improvement of endemic programmes.
Assuntos
Controle de Doenças Transmissíveis/organização & administração , Zoonoses/prevenção & controle , Animais , Região do Caribe , América Central , Controle de Doenças Transmissíveis/estatística & dados numéricos , Prioridades em Saúde/organização & administração , Prioridades em Saúde/estatística & dados numéricos , Humanos , América do Sul , Inquéritos e QuestionáriosRESUMO
The American region has pledged to eliminate dog-mediated human rabies by 2015. As part of these efforts, we describe the findings of a desk and field mission review of Haiti's rabies situation by the end of 2013. While government officials recognize the importance of dog-mediated rabies control, and the national rabies plan adequately contemplates the basic capacities to that effect, regular and sufficient implementation, for example, of dog vaccination, is hampered by limited funding. Compounding insufficient funding and human resources, official surveillance figures do not accurately reflect the risk to the population, as evidenced by the large number of rabid dogs detected by focalized and enhanced surveillance activities conducted by the Ministry of Agriculture, Natural Resources and Rural Development (MARNDR) and the Health and Population Ministry (MSPP) with the technical assistance of the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Although international support is common, either in the form of on-the-ground technical support or donations of immunobiologicals, it is not comprehensive. In addition, there is limited coordination with MARNDR/MSPP and with other actors at the strategic or operational level due to human resources limitations. Given these findings, the 2015 elimination goal in the region is compromised by the situation in Haiti where control of the disease is not yet in sight despite the best efforts of the resolute national officials. More importantly, dog-mediated rabies is still a threat to the Haitian population.