RESUMEN

INTRODUCTION: The operating room is no longer the ideal place for early surgica training of cardiothoracic surgery residents, forcing the search for simulation-based learning options. The study's aim was the construction and surgicaltraining of coronary anastomosis in a portable, low-cost, homemade simulator. METHODS: This is an observational, analytical, and multicenter study. The simulator was built with common materials and was evaluated with the Objective Structured Assessment ofTechnical Skills (or OSATS) Modified. All junior and senior residents from nine national cardiothoracic surgery centers were considered for 90 days. Operative skill acquisition and time in the creation of side-to-side (S-T-S), end-to-side (E-T-S), and end-to-end (E-T-E) coronary anastomoses were evaluated. All sessions were recorded and evaluated by a single senior cardiothoracic surgeon during two time periods. RESULTS: One hundred and forty residents were assessed in 270 sessions. In junior residents, a significant improvement in final scores was identified in S-T-S (use of Castroviejo needle holder, needle angles, and needle transfer) (P<0.05). In seniors, a significant improvement was identified in S-T-S (graft orientation, appropriate spacing, use of forceps, angles, and needle transfer) anastomoses (P<0.05). A significant improvement in the final anastomosis time of senior residents over junior residents was identified in S-T-S (8.11 vs. 11.22 minutes), E-T-S (7.93 vs. 10.10 minutes), and E-T-E (6.56 vs. 9.68 minutes) (P=0.039). CONCLUSION: Our portable and low-cost coronary anastomosis simulator is effective in improving operative skills in cardiothoracic surgery residents; therefore, skills acquired through simulation-based training transfer have a positive impact on the surgical environment.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

Introduction: There is a controversy in minimally invasive colorectal procedures regarding choosing optimal technique between intra-corporeal (ICA) and extra-corporeal anastomosis (ECA). Previous studies recognize the short-term benefits in right hemicolectomy with intra-corporeal approach; however, ICA can result in increased operative difficulty. The aim of this study is to understand attitudes towards teaching ICA in colorectal procedures and how this varies between subspeciality training. Methods: Active members of General Surgeons Australia were contacted through email to participate in a voluntary, unincentivized survey. Demographic details were collected and participants were asked to rate agreement for simulation-based training for increasing adoption of ICA through a Likert scale and when preferences for teaching ICA. Descriptive statistics were completed to describe frequencies and ordinal regression was completed to determine factors for Likert scale question. Results: There were 43 respondents and most participants recognized that ECA was easier to teach trainees and should be taught first. 53.5% of respondents recognized that simulation-based training would assist the adoption of ICA. Surgeons who routinely close bowel or enteric defects intra-corporeally are 354% more likely to show an interest in simulation-based training for adopting ICA, however, surgeons who are not involved in teaching trainees did not show an interest in simulation-based training. Conclusion: There is significant agreement that ECA forms the basis to learn ICA and simulation-based training would assist with the uptake of ICA. However, a multimodal approach, including expanding training avenues and providing financial incentives, would be necessary to enhance the adoption of ICA in colorectal surgery.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: Training in anastomosis is fundamental in neurosurgery due to the precision and dexterity required. Biological models, although realistic, present limitations such as availability, ethical concerns, and the risk of biological contamination. Synthetic models, on the other hand, offer durability and standardized conditions, although they sometimes lack anatomical realism. This study aims to evaluate and compare the efficiency of anastomosis training models in the intra-extracranial cerebral bypass procedure, identifying those characteristics that enhance optimal microsurgical skill development and participant experience. METHODS: A neurosurgery workshop was held from March 2024 to June 2024 with 5 vascular techniques and the participation of 22 surgeons. The models tested were the human placenta, the Wistar rat, the chicken wing artery, the nasogastric feeding tube, and the UpSurgeOn Mycro simulator. The scales used to measure these models were the Main Characteristics Score and the Evaluation Score. These scores allowed us to measure, qualitatively and quantitatively, durability, anatomical similarity, variety of simulation scenarios, risk of biological contamination, ethical considerations and disadvantages with specific infrastructure. RESULTS: The human placenta model, Wistar rat model, and UpSurgeOn model were identified as the most effective for training. The human placenta and Wistar rat models were highly regarded for anatomical realism, while the UpSurgeOn model excelled in durability and advanced simulation scenarios. Ethical and cost implications were also considered. CONCLUSIONS: The study identifies the human placenta and UpSurgeOn models as optimal for training in intra-extracranial bypass procedures, emphasizing the need for diverse and effective training models in neurosurgery.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: Retrospective studies and randomized controlled trials support the safety of laparoscopic complete mesocolic excision (CME) for the treatment of right-sided colon cancer (RSCC). Few studies, however, examine the learning curve of this operation and its impact on safety during an implementation period. We aim to evaluate the learning curve and safety of the implementation of laparoscopic CME with intracorporeal anastomosis for RSCC. METHODS: Consecutive patients undergoing a laparoscopic right colectomy with intracorporeal anastomosis for RSCC between January 2016 and June 2023 were included. Clinical, perioperative, and histopathological variables were collected. Correlation and cumulative sum (CUSUM) analyses between the operating time and case number were performed. Breakpoints of the learning curve were estimated using the broken-line model. CME and conventional laparoscopic right colectomy outcomes were compared after propensity score matching (PSM). RESULTS: Two hundred and ninety patients underwent laparoscopic right colectomy during study period. One hundred and eight met inclusion criteria. After PSM, 56 non-CME and 28 CME patients were compared. CME group had a non-statistically significant tendency to a longer operating time (201 versus 195 min; p = 0.657) and a shorter hospital stay (3 versus 4 days; p = 0.279). No significant differences were found in total complication rates or their profile. Correlation analysis identified a significant trend toward operating time reduction with increasing case numbers (Pearson correlation coefficient = - 0.624; p = 0.001). According to the CUSUM analysis, an institutional learning curve was deemed completed after 13 cases and the broken-line model identified three phases: learning (1-6 cases), consolidation (7-13 cases), and mastery (after 13 cases). CONCLUSION: The learning curve of laparoscopic CME for RSCC can be achieved after 13 cases in centers with experience in advanced laparoscopic surgery and surgeons with familiarity with this technique. Its implementation within this setting seems to be as safe as performing a conventional right colectomy.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: Supermicrosurgery demands more refined skills compared to traditional microsurgery, necessitating comprehensive training prior to clinical implementation. Despite the existence of various training models, they often fall short in terms of cost, ethical considerations, and infection risk. Our objective was to develop and evaluate novel training models for supermicrosurgery that are cost-effective, ethical, and risk-free. METHODS: We fabricated tubes using polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) liquid glue, polyvinyl acetate resin (PAR) wood glue, and hydrocolloid dressing (HCD), aiming to identify suitable, low-cost candidates for a supermicrosurgery training model. These tubes were anastomosed under a microscope using 10-0 or 11-0 nylon sutures. We assessed the time and cost involved in tube fabrication, their diameters, and the overall feasibility of the models. RESULTS: The average time and cost to fabricate a 15-mm-long luminal tube were 33.5 min and 0.02 USD for the PVA group, 23 min and 0.02 USD for the PAR group, and 63 s and 0.40 USD for the HCD group, respectively. The average diameter of the tubes was 0.49, 0.58, and 1.55 mm in the PVA, PAR, and HCD groups, respectively. The PVA and PAR tubes, with their transparent and thin walls, facilitated easier evaluation of anastomosis patency compared to the HCD tubes. CONCLUSION: We successfully used non-living materials to develop new supermicrosurgery training models, characterized by their low cost, absence of ethical concerns, and elimination of infection risk. The PAR and PVA tubes, in particular, are suitable for resident training in supermicrosurgery.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

Introduction: As surgical technologies grow, so too do demands on surgical trainees to master increasing numbers of skill sets. With the rise of endovascular surgery, trainees have fewer opportunities to practice open vascular techniques in the operating room. Simulation can bridge this gap. However, existing published open vascular simulation curricula are basic or based on expensive models. Methods: We iteratively developed an open vascular skills curriculum for second-year surgery residents comprising six 2-hour sessions. We refined the curriculum based on feedback from learners and faculty. The curriculum required skilled facilitators, vascular instruments, and tissue models. We evaluated the latest iteration with a survey and by assessing participants' technical skills using the Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills (OSATS) form. Results: Over the past 10 years, 101 residents have participated in the curriculum. Nine of 13 residents who participated in the latest curricular iteration completed the survey. All respondents rated the sessions as excellent and strongly agreed that they had improved their abilities to perform anastomoses with tissue and prosthetic. Facilitators completed 18 OSATS forms for residents in the fifth and sixth sessions of the latest iteration. Residents scored well overall, with a median 26.5 (interquartile range: 24-29) out of a possible score of 35, with highest scores on knowledge of instruments. Discussion: This simulation-based curriculum facilitates open vascular surgical skill acquisition among surgery residents. The curriculum allows residents to acquire critical vascular skills that are challenging to learn in an increasingly demanding operative setting.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: Surgical reconstruction is a crucial stage in various surgeries, including pancreaticoduodenectomy, as it can significantly affect the surgical results. The objective was to design a suture force feedback (SFF) device that can precisely measure the suture force during surgical closures. Afterward, the device was used to train junior surgeons in surgical closure techniques. METHODS: The SFF was used to capture the suture force data of experienced surgeons. This data was utilized to train and assess junior surgeons. The SFF device had 2 tactile-based force sensors that measured the applied force. Whenever the applied force was not within the optimal force range, the device provided feedback to the surgeon. A workshop was conducted to train junior surgeons in surgical closure techniques to improve their suturing skills. RESULTS: Thirty-seven junior surgeons were enrolled in this training, of whom only 24 completed the 30-day training program. The pre-assessment results revealed that the force exerted by junior surgeons during suture knot-tying was uneven compared with that of the experienced surgeons, with a significant difference in the force exerted per knot throw (P = 0.005. Before the training program, junior surgeons applied a force of 3.89 ± 0.43 N, which was more than twice the force applied by experienced surgeons (1.75 ± 0.12 N). However, after completing the 30-day training program, their force improved to 2.35 ± 0.13 N. CONCLUSIONS: The SFF device was shown to be an encouraging training tool for improving the surgical closure dexterity and technique of the participating junior surgeons.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

INTRODUCTION: Communication is fundamental to effective surgical coaching. This can be challenging for training during image-guided procedures where coaches and trainees need to articulate technical details on a monitor. Telestration devices that annotate on monitors remotely could potentially overcome these limitations and enhance the coaching experience. This study aims to evaluate the value of a novel telestration device in surgical coaching. METHODS: A randomized-controlled trial was designed. All participants watched a video demonstrating the task followed by a baseline performance assessment and randomization into either control group (conventional verbal coaching without telestration) or telestration group (verbal coaching with telestration). Coaching for a simulated laparoscopic small bowel anastomosis on a dry lab model was done by a faculty surgeon. Following the coaching session, participants underwent a post-coaching performance assessment of the same task. Assessments were recorded and rated by blinded reviewers using a modified Global Rating Scale of the Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills (OSATS). Coaching sessions were also recorded and compared in terms of mentoring moments; guidance misinterpretations, questions/clarifications by trainees, and task completion time. A 5-point Likert scale was administered to obtain feedback. RESULTS: Twenty-four residents participated (control group 13, telestration group 11). Improvements in some elements of the OSATS scale were noted in the Telestration arm but there was no statistical significance in the overall score between the two groups. Mentoring moments were more in the telestration Group. Amongst the telestration Group, 55% felt comfortable that they could perform this task independently, compared to only 8% amongst the control group and 82% would recommend the use of telestration tools here. CONCLUSION: There is demonstrated educational value of this novel telestration device mainly in the non-technical aspects of the interaction by enhancing the coaching experience with improvement in communication and greater mentoring moments between coach and trainee.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

OBJECTIVE: We evaluated the effectiveness of a consistent and structured self-practice coronary anastomosis program using a homemade low-fidelity beating-heart simulator. METHODS: An intermediary trainee was subjected to an 8-week structured self-practice program. The program was divided into 2 parts of nonbeating and beating practices with a minimum number of timed anastomoses. Each part was followed by an assessment using an objective skills assessment tool score. The beating-heart simulator was built using motorized toy blocks connected wirelessly to a smartphone application. This was coded to enable rate selection. A junior consultant was compared to the subject at the end of the program. Both were tasked to perform 1 coronary anastomosis for both off-pump coronary artery bypass (OPCAB) and minimally invasive CAB (MICS) setup. The primary outcomes were anastomotic time and score compared with the junior consultant. Secondary outcomes were progression of anastomotic time and score throughout the program. RESULTS: Overall performance of the studied subject approached the performance of the junior consultant in terms of time (OPCAB, 489 vs 605 s; MICS, 712 vs 652 s) and scores (OPCAB, 21 vs 20.7; MICS, 19 vs 20.6). There were inverse correlations between anastomosis time and number of practices for both nonbeating and beating anastomoses. Overall improvement was observed in terms of assessment scoring by 26.6%. CONCLUSIONS: A structured self-practice program using an affordable and accessible simulator was able to help trainees overcome the MICS anastomosis learning curve quicker when introduced earlier. This may encourage earlier adoption of MICS among surgeons.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

AIM: A new simulation model and training curriculum for laparoscopic bilioenteric anastomosis has been developed. Currently, this concept lacks evidence for the transfer of skills from simulation to clinical settings. This study was conducted to determine whether training with a three-dimensional (3D) bilioenteric anastomosis model result in greater transfer of skills than traditional training methods involving video observation and a general suture model. METHODS: Fifteen general surgeons with no prior experience in laparoscopic biliary-enteric anastomosis were included in this study and randomised into three training groups: video observation only, practice using a general suture model, and practice using a 3D-printed biliary-enteric anastomosis model. Following five training sessions, each surgeon was asked to perform a laparoscopic biliary-enteric anastomosis procedure on an isolated swine organ model. The operative time and performance scores of the procedure were recorded and compared among the three training groups. RESULTS: The operation time in the 3D-printed model group was significantly shorter than the suture and video observation groups ( P =0.040). Furthermore, the performance score of the 3D-printed model group was significantly higher than those of the suture and video observation groups ( P =0.001). Finally, the goal score for laparoscopic biliary-enteric anastomosis in the isolated swine organ model was significantly higher in the 3D model group than in the suture and video observation groups ( P =0.004). CONCLUSIONS: The utilisation of a novel 3D-printed model for simulation training in laparoscopic biliary-enteric anastomosis facilitates improved skill acquisition and transferability to an animal setting compared with traditional training techniques.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: Microsurgical training should be implemented with consideration of operative difficulties that occur in actual clinical situations. We evaluated the effectiveness of a novel clinical scenario simulator for step-by-step microsurgical training that progressed from conventional training to escalated training with additional obstacles. METHODS: A training device was designed according to multiple and intricate clinical microsurgery scenarios. Twenty surgical residents with no experience in microsurgery were randomly assigned to either the control group (conventional training curricula, n = 10) or the experimental group (step-by-step training courses, n = 10). After 4 weeks of laboratory practice, the participants were scheduled to perform their first microvascular anastomoses on patients in an operating room. The Global Rating Scale (GRS) scores and operative duration were used to compare microsurgical skills between the two groups. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in the participants' baseline characteristics before microsurgical training between the groups with respect to age, sex, postgraduate year, surgical specialty, or mean GRS score (p < 0.05). There were also no significant differences in recipient sites between the two groups (p = 0.735). After training, the GRS scores in both groups were significantly improved (p = 0.000). However, in the actual microsurgical situations, the GRS scores were significantly higher in the experimental than control group (p < 0.05). There was no significant difference in the operative duration between the two groups (p < 0.13). CONCLUSION: Compared with a traditional training program, this step-by-step microsurgical curriculum based on our clinical scenario simulator results in significant improvement in acquisition of microsurgical skills.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Surgical simulation models in cranial neurosurgery are needed to allow affordable, accessible, and validated practice in resident education. Current bypass anastomosis practice models revolve around basic tube tying or complex animal and 3-dimensional models. This study sought to design and validate a 3-dimensional printed model for intracranial anastomosis training. METHODS: A computer-aided design (CAD) generic skull was uploaded into Meshmixer (v.3.5), and a 55-mm opening was created on the right side, mimicking a standard orbitozygomatic craniotomy. The model was rotated 15° upward and 35° left, before a 10-mm square frame was added 80-mm deep to the right orbit. The CAD model was uploaded to GrabCAD and printed using a J750 PolyJet 3D printer before being paired with a vascular anastomosis kit. The model was validated with standardized assessments of residents and attendings by simulating an "M2 to P2" bypass. The Rochester Bypass Training Score (RBTS) was created to assess bypass patency, back wall suturing, and suture quality. Postsimulation survey data regarding the realism and usefulness of the simulation were collected. RESULTS: Five junior residents (Postgraduate Year 1-4), 3 senior residents (Postgraduate Year 5-7), and 2 attendings were participated. The mean operative time in minutes was as follows: junior residents 78, senior residents 33, and attendings 50. The RBTS means were as follows: junior residents 2.4, senior residents 4.0, and attendings 5.0. Participants agreed that the model was realistic, useful for improving operative technique, and would increase comfort in bypass procedures. There are a few different printing options, varying in model infill and printing material used. For this experiment, a mix of Vero plastics were used totaling $309.09 per model; however, using the more common printing material polylactic acid brings the cost to $17.27 for a comparable model. CONCLUSION: This study presents an affordable, realistic, and educational intracranial vascular anastomosis simulator and introduces the RBTS for assessment.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

PURPOSE: To evaluate the gain of microsurgical skills and competencies by urology residents, using low-fidelity experimental models. METHODS: The study involved the use of training boards, together with a low-fidelity microsurgery simulator, developed using a 3D printer. The model consists in two silicone tubes, coated with a resin, measuring 10 cm in length and with internal and external diameters of 0.5 and 1.5 mm. The support for the ducts is composed by a small box, developed with polylactic acid. The evaluation of the gain of skills and competencies in microsurgery occurred throughout a training course consisting of five training sessions. The first sessions (S1-S4) took place at weekly intervals and the last session (S5) was performed three months after S4. During sessions, were analyzed: the speed of performing microsurgical sutures in the pre and post-training and the performance of each resident through the Objective Structure Assessment of Technical Skill (OSATS) and Student Satisfaction Self-Confidence tools in Learning (SSSCL). RESULTS: There was a decrease in the time needed to perform the anastomosis (p=0.0019), as well as a progressive increase in the score in the OSATS over during sessions S1 to S4. At S5, there was a slightly decrease in performance (p<0.0001), however, remaining within the expected plateau for the gain of skills and competences. The SSSCL satisfaction scale showed an overall approval rating of 96.9%, with a Cronback alpha coefficient of 83%. CONCLUSIONS: The low-fidelity simulation was able to guarantee urology residents a solid gain in skills and competencies in microsurgery.

Asunto(s)

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this paper is to describe the techniques and process of developing and testing a take-home surgical anastomosis simulation model. DESIGN: Through an iterative process, a simulation model was customized and designed to target specific skill development and performance objectives that focused on anastomotic techniques in thoracic surgery and consist of 3D printed and silicone molded components. Various manufacturing techniques such as silicone dip spin coating and injection molding have been described in this paper and explored as part of the research and development process. The final prototype is a low-cost, take-home model with reusable and replaceable components. SETTING: The study took place at a single-center quaternary care university-affiliated hospital. PARTICIPANTS: The participants included in the model testing were 10 senior thoracic surgery trainees who completed an in-person training session held during an annual hands- on thoracic surgery simulation course. Feedback was then collected in the form of an evaluation of the model from participants. RESULTS: All 10 participants had an opportunity to test the model and complete at least 1 pulmonary artery and bronchial anastomosis. The overall experience was rated highly, with minor feedback provided regarding the set- up and fidelity of the materials used for the anastomoses. Overall, the trainees agreed that the model was suitable for teaching advanced anastomotic techniques and expressed an interest in being able to use this model to practice skill development. CONCLUSIONS: Developed simulation model can be easily reduced, with customized components that accurately simulate real-life vascular and bronchial components suitable for training of anastomoses technique amongst senior thoracic surgery trainees.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

INTRODUCTION: General surgery residents need to master the hand-sewn bowel anastomosis (HSBA) technique. However, practice opportunities outside of the operating room are rare, and commercial simulators are often costly. The objective of this study is to assess the efficacy of a new, affordable silicone small bowel simulator, made with a three-dimensional (3D) printed mold, as a training tool to learn this technique. METHODS: This was a single-blinded pilot randomized controlled trial comparing two groups of eight junior surgical residents. All participants completed a pretest using an inexpensive, custom developed 3D-printed simulator. Next, participants randomized to the experimental group practiced the HSBA skill at home (eight sessions), while those randomized to the control group did not receive any hands-on practice opportunities. A posttest was done using the same simulator as for the pretest and practice sessions, and the retention-transfer test was performed on an anesthetized porcine model. Pretests, posttests and retention-transfer tests were filmed and graded by a blinded evaluator using assessments of technical skills, quality of final product, and tests of procedural knowledge. RESULTS: The experimental group significantly improved after practicing with the model (P = 0.01), while an equivalent improvement was not noted in the control group (P = 0.07). Moreover, the experimental group's performance remained stable between the posttest and the retention-transfer test (P = 0.95). CONCLUSIONS: Our 3D-printed simulator is an affordable and efficacious tool to teach residents the HSBA technique. It allows development of surgical skills that are transferable to an in vivo model.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

We have recently incorporated simple modifications of the konjac flour noodle model to enable DIY home microsurgical training by (i) placing a smartphone on a mug to act as a microscope with at least ×3.5-5 magnification, and (ii) rather than cannulating with a 22G needle as described by others, we have found that cannulation with a 23G needle followed by a second pass with an 18G needle will create a lumen (approximately 0.83 mm) without an overly thick and unrealistic "vessel" wall. The current setup, however, did not allow realistic evaluation of anastomotic patency as the noodles became macerated after application of standard microvascular clamps, which also did not facilitate practice of back-wall anastomoses. In order to simulate the actual operative environment as much as possible, we introduced the use of 3D-printed microvascular clamps. These were modified from its previous iteration (suitable for use in silastic and chicken thigh vessels), and video recordings were submitted for internal validation by senior surgeons. A "wet" operative field where the konjac noodle lumen can be distended or collapsed, unlike other nonliving models, was noted by senior surgeons. With the 3D clamps, the noodle could now be flipped over for back-wall anastomosis and allowed patency testing upon completion as it did not become macerated, unlike that from clinical microvascular clamps. The perceived advantages of this model are numerous. Not only does it comply with the 3Rs of simulation-based training, but it can also reduce the associated costs of training by up to a hundred-fold or more when compared to a traditional rat course and potentially be extended to low-middle income countries without routine access to microsurgical training for capacity development. That it can be utilized remotely also bodes well with the current limitations on face-to-face training due to COVID restrictions and lockdowns.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

Introduction and Objective: With introduction of the da Vinci single-port (SP) system, we evaluated which multiport (MP) robotic skills are naturally transferable to the SP platform. Methods: Three groups of urologists: Group 1 (5 inexperienced in MP and SP), Group 2 (5 experienced in MP without SP experience), and Group 3 (2 experienced in both MP and SP) were recruited to complete a validated urethrovesical anastomosis simulation using MP followed by SP robots. Performance was graded using both GEARS and RACE scales. Subjective cognitive load measurements (Surg-TLX and difficulty ratings [/20] of instrument collisions camera and EndoWrist movement) were collected. Results: GEARS and RACE scores for Groups 1 and 3 were maintained on switching from MP to SP (Group 3 scored significantly higher on both systems). Surg-TLX and difficulty scores were also maintained for both groups on switching from MP and SP except for a significant increase in SP camera movement (+7.2, p = 0.03) in Group 1 compared to Group 3 that maintained low scores on both. Group 2 demonstrated significant lower GEARS (-2.9, p = 0.047) and RACE (-5.1, p = 0.011) scores on SP vs MP. On subanalysis, GEARS subscores for force sensitivity and robotic control (-0.7, p = 0.04; -0.9, p = 0.02) and RACE subscores for needle entry, needle driving, and tissue approximation (-0.9, p = 0.01; -1.0, p = 0.02; -1.0, p < 0.01) significantly decreased. GEARS (depth perception, bimanual dexterity, and efficiency) and RACE subscores (needle positioning and suture placement) were maintained. All participants scored significantly lower in knot tying on the SP robot (-1.0, p = 0.03; -1.2, p = 0.02, respectively). Group 2 reported higher Surg-TLX (+13 pts, p = 0.015) and difficulty ratings on SP vs MP (+11.8, p < 0.01; +13.6, p < 0.01; +14 pts, p < 0.01). Conclusions: The partial skill transference across robots raises the question regarding SP-specific training for urologists proficient in MP. Novices maintained difficulty scores and cognitive load across platforms, suggesting that concurrent SP and MP training may be preferred.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

In microsurgery training, where the first steps occur in a safe simulated environment, we believe there is a lack of emphasis on well reflected commonly occurring mistakes; education manuals provide stepwise instructions on performing tasks but do not list common mistakes and ways to avoid them. It is well acknowledged that the majority of vascular anastomotic complications are attributed to technical errors, however the validated global rating scales that are used to assess microsurgical competency do not address errors and how to avoid making them - potentially preventing devastating failures. Our aim is to improve and streamline constructive feedback in microsurgical education by use of an error-based learning resource. By referring to our '13 errors' graphic, teachers and students can refer to specific errors they have made, and quickly revise these with error-specific feedback, with and without supervision. The '13 errors' table enables identification errors, explanation as to why these may have occurred, and constructive feedback in order to rectify the mistake.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: Microsurgery is a technically demanding aspect of surgery that is integral to a variety of sub-specialties. Microsurgery is required in high-risk cases where time is limited and pressure is high, so there is increasing demand for skills acquisition beforehand. The aim of this review was to analyse the available literature on validated microsurgical assessment tools. METHODS: Covidence was used to screen papers for inclusion. Keywords included 'microsurgery', 'simulation', 'end-product assessment' and 'competence'. Inclusion criteria specified simulation models which demonstrate training and assessment of skill acquisition simultaneously. Tools which were used for training independently of technical assessment were excluded and so were tools which did not include a microvascular anastomosis. Each assessment tool was evaluated for validity, bias, complexity and fidelity and reliability using PRISMA and SWiM guidelines. RESULTS: Thirteen distinct tools were validated for use in microsurgical assessment. These can be divided into overall assessment and end-product assessment. Ten tools assessed the 'journey' of the operation, and three tools were specifically end-product assessments. All tools achieved construct validity. Criterion validity was only assessed for the UWOMSA1 and GRS.2 Interrater reliability was demonstrated for each tool except the ISSLA3 and SAMS.4 Four of the tools addressed demonstrate predictive validity.4-7 CONCLUSION: Thirteen assessment tools achieve variable validity for use in microsurgery. Interrater reliability is demonstrated for 11 of the 13 tools. The GRS and UWOMSA achieve intrarater reliability. The End Product Intimal Assessment tool and the Imperial College of Surgical Assessment device were valid tools for objective assessment of microsurgical skill.

Asunto(s)