RESUMEN

Guidelines from the Netherlands describe that unnatural deaths should be investigated by a forensic physician and Crime Scene Technicians, but this is not always the case. In this study, we aimed to determine what predicts the non-attendance of the Crime Scene Technicians at the scene of the death of suicides in the police region in Rotterdam, the Netherlands. Data of 315 suicides (2016-2017) that have been externally examined by forensic physicians and reports from the Crime Scene Technicians were analysed. Statistical analysis was performed to determine the factors predicting the involvement of the Crime Scene Technicians at the scene of death. The Crime Scene Technicians were not attending in 23% (n = 72) cases, and over half of these cases were not found in the registration system of the Crime Scene Technicians. About some the Crime Scene Technicians was not informed. Predictors of the non-attendance of the Crime Scene Technicians were suicide by poisoning, the individual was found by an acquaintance or family, a history of suicide attempts and examination of the deceased in the hospital. In this study, we observed that the Crime Scene Technicians were sometimes not attending the investigation of apparent suicides. More research on this topic should be done to investigate the value of the presence of the Crime Scene Technicians at the scene before concluding that non-attendance of Crime Scene Technicians on-site influences the quality of the scene of death investigation and corresponding conclusions. Since 2017, several quality improvements were made, but an (inter)national conjoint protocol for uniform and structural suicide investigation could secure the quality of the scene of death investigation of suicides and would provide information useful for evaluation.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

Forensic clinicians work with some of the most vulnerable members of society. Despite this it is one of the few areas of front line, undifferentiated healthcare in the UK that does not come under the National Health Service. The Faculty of Forensic & Legal Medicine (FFLM) has produced quality standards guidance for over a decade to support good practice in clinical forensic medicine. In April 2021 we surveyed their membership to ascertain whether clinicians working in the field felt that adequate standards were being maintained. The results demonstrate significant variability in the implementation of standards in both general forensic and sexual offence medicine for both adults and children. They highlight that despite some pockets of excellent practice there are significant areas of concern.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

Forensic physicians in the region of Amsterdam routinely collect blood and urine samples during external examinations. A rapid on-site multidrug test is used to screen the urine samples for the presence of commonly used drugs classes. Urine and blood samples are sent to the laboratory for additional toxicological analysis. This study aimed to investigate how the substances found in urine using the on-site multidrug test relate to the substances identified with laboratory methods. In 2018 and 2019, 465 cases underwent an on-site multidrug test as well as toxicological laboratory analyses and were included in this study. Fifty-three percent (n = 247) of these cases included a positive on-site multidrug test for at least one substance. The level of total agreement between the on-site multidrug test performed by the forensic physician and the laboratory analyses either in urine or in blood varied per substance groups, with the best results for barbiturates, cocaine, ecstasy and methadone. In conclusion, the on-site multidrug test appeared to perform well for certain substance groups and is an economical and rapid tool. However, the results from the laboratory analyses in blood occasionally provided additional insights concerning the circumstances that could be of importance in the cause of death.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

INTRODUCTION: In 2012 and 2013 a movie and a book about a 'dignified end of life' were published in the Netherlands. These items described suicide using an 'exit bag' to establish asphyxiation using helium (the helium method). 'Right-to-die-organisations' inform the elderly about this method. The purpose of this study is to investigate whether the use of suicidal asphyxiation by means of the helium method substituted other, related, methods following its publication in the Netherlands. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We analysed suicides in the Netherlands over the period from 1 July 2012 to 30 June 2019. We compared the number of deaths caused by the helium method with other, related, cases. Secondly, we related these deaths to the total number of inhabitants and suicides recorded by Statistics Netherlands. RESULTS: The study showed a stable trend in the use of the helium method in the period 2012-2019 and this was the same for the other, related methods. Individuals using the helium method were significantly younger than those using other, related, methods. At the scene of death, information about suicide and suicide notes were found more often at 'helium method' cases than with the 'other, related, methods' cases. Family was significantly more often present during a helium method suicide than during suicide by other, related, methods. DISCUSSION: The number of suicides by the helium method and other, related, cases is stable in the Netherlands over the past years. Therefore, we conclude that there is no substitution effect within this category of suicides. Whilst 'right-to-die-organisations' strive to inform the old and sick of the helium method, it is noteworthy that the individuals using the helium method are significantly younger than the individuals who choose other, related, methods.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: Research has shown a higher prevalence of individuals lying dead unnoticed in their homes (domestic-setting corpses) in Amsterdam, compared to adjacent less urbanized cities and villages. OBJECTIVE: To determine if there is a difference in incidence of domestic-setting corpses in the four major cities in the Netherlands and identifying demographic patterns accounting for possible differences. METHODS: Data of domestic-setting corpses with a post mortem interval of at least 14 days were extracted from forensic registrations of the four largest cities in the Netherlands. These data were analysed using Poisson-regression and compared to numbers of Statistics Netherlands to calculate the incidence rate of domestic-setting corpses. Only single households were included. RESULTS: The incidence of DSC14 is not significantly different between Amsterdam, The Hague and Rotterdam. The incidence rate of DSC in these cities is almost twice as high compared to Utrecht (corrected for age and sex 1,9; 95% CI:1,1-3,0). CONCLUSION: The incidence rate of DSC14 is comparable in the three largest cities of the Netherlands, and significantly higher compared to the smallest of the four (Utrecht). Possibly the lower number in Utrecht is related to less loneliness, a higher social participation and a difference in architecture.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

INTRODUCTION: The three 'advised' suicide methods are helium asphyxiation, voluntarily stop eating and drinking and the use of a deadly dose of medication such as barbiturates. The aim of this study was to analyse the number of suicides resulting from barbiturate overdose and examine the influence of publications and internet on this suicide method in the two larger cities of the Netherlands. METHODS: Data of suicides by medication and drugs overdose were extracted from the electronic registration systems of the forensic physicians of the district of Amsterdam and Rotterdam over the period 1 January 2006-31 December 2017. We analysed whether or not the number of suicides using barbiturate overdose has significantly risen since 2013. This was the year 'right-to-die-organisations' informed individuals about this method and a book was published describing this as a humane death. In addition, a regression analysis was used to examine which factors predict a suicide resulting from barbiturate overdose. RESULTS: A total of 553 overdose suicides were identified and 91 suicides resulting from barbiturate overdose were included for further evaluation. During 2013-2017 there were significantly (p < 0.00) more suicides resulting from barbiturate overdose compared to 2007-2012. Individuals using barbiturate overdose to die by suicide were significantly (p < 0.00) older than those using other medication and drugs (65 years compared to 55 years respectively). 48% of these cases were male. In barbiturate suicides, information sources (books or information on the internet, p < 0.01) and the presence of family during suicide (p < 0.00) occurred significantly more often than in suicides resulting from other medication and/or drugs overdose. The odds for barbiturate suicides were 4.8 higher (CI 2.6-9.2) after 2013 compared to before 2013 after correction for age, sex, city and postmortem toxicology results. DISCUSSION: Our data showed a rise in suicides resulting from barbiturate overdose whereas the total number of inhabitants and suicides resulting from medication overdose has remained more or less constant. Easy access of information or medication through the internet and 'right-to-die-organisations' may have directly impacted the rise in suicides resulting from an overdose of barbiturates. To our knowledge this is the first study analysing the rise of barbiturate suicides and the influence of media in published literature.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

Although the physical and psychological consequences of sexual violence can be severe, many victims do not report the violence to the police force. The current study examined the characteristics and the post-decisional attitude of the non-reporting sexual violence victims. In total, 287 victims of sexual violence completed an anonymous online questionnaire that assessed characteristics of the violence, whether or not the crime was reported, reasons for not reporting, and aspects that would have convinced non-reporters to report in retrospect. Eighty percent of the victims did not report the most recent sexual violence incident to the police ( n = 229). Nevertheless, 65% of the non-reporting victims ( n = 148) in retrospect would have reported to the police ("potential reporters"). Specific reasons for non-reporting and incident characteristics appear to relate to the post-decision attitude of non-reporting victims of sexual violence. "Lack of evidence" and "feelings of shame, guilt, and other emotions" appear to be more frequently mentioned by potential reporters as reasons for their decision to not report as compared with the definitive non-reporters. Likewise, being raped or sexually assaulted is predictive of potential reporting. Our findings are useful for policy makers to develop strategies to increase reporting rates of sexual violence victims.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

When treating unconscious patients believed to have been victims of sexual assault, forensic physicians must decide whether to conduct physical examinations in order to collect evidence while patients are unconscious and cannot consent. The choice is urgent: potential evidence may be lost before the patient regains the ability to consent. The physician's choice affects not only the patient's bodily integrity, but also their ability to pursue criminal and potentially civil justice remedies if they were assaulted. This article bases its discussion on one such real-life situation. It first examines ethical models relevant to deciding whether to take evidence and finds that no one approach produces morally satisfactory outcomes in every case. It then examines the legal framework guiding these decisions, finding that while collecting evidence without consent may well be permissible under New South Wales (NSW) legislation, relevant guidelines disallow it, placing physicians in a legal grey-area. The article concludes with practical recommendations to address these ethical, professional and legal challenges.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: Police detainees are known to have inferior health. This study identifies the number of former police detainees who received medical care among deaths examined by forensic physicians and presents their death characteristics. METHODS: We included all deaths that were examined by forensic physicians of the Public Health Service Amsterdam from 2013 to 2015. Patient files of subjects were scanned for the presence of a prior medical consultation in the police cell and death characteristics were collected from post-mortem examination reports. We performed statistical analyses to discover what characteristics at post-mortem examination were associated with a prior consultation in the police cell. RESULTS: We identified n = 2618 subjects that met the inclusion criteria. Eight percent of subjects had one or more medical consultation(s) in the police cell in a mean follow up time of 4.8 (±3.0) years. No difference was found in the share of unnatural deaths between subjects with and without a prior consultation (68%), but distribution of death causes differed significantly. Male gender OR 2.3 (p < 0.001), age OR 0.98 (p < 0.001), unspecified unnatural dead OR 1.8 (p = 0.002), crime related dead OR 2.2 (p = 0.012) and accidental drowning and submerging death OR 4.6 (p < 0.001) were independently associated with the presence of an earlier consultation in the police cell. CONCLUSION: Our data suggest that a small percentage of police detainees seen by forensic physicians for provision of medical care are also examined after death by these physicians, typically young males who seem to display risk-taking and criminal behavior resulting in unnatural dead.

Asunto(s)

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

Resumen El análisis científico de la escena del crimen es de trascendental importancia en la investigación judicial. Es función de un equipo, del cual el médico forense es parte obligatoria. El conocimiento de las circunstancias y antecedentes del hecho investigado, junto con el estudio del lugar y del cadáver, constituyen elementos indispensables para el correcto abordaje del cuerpo en la necropsia; de esta manera, se cumplirá con el objetivo primordial del trabajo pericial médico forense: contribuir al esclarecimiento de la comisión de un hecho delictivo con resultado de muerte. En este artículo se ofrece una actualización del tema de la participación del médico forense en la escena del crimen, considerando la realidad de la práctica pericial médico legal en Panamá.

Abstract The scientific analysis of the crime scene is of transcendental importance in the judicial investigation. It is a function of a team, of which the forensic physician is an indispensable part. Knowledge of the circumstances and background of the researched fact, together with the study of the place and the corpse, constitute essential elements for the correct approach to the body at postmortem examination; in this way, the primary objective of the forensic medical expert work: contribute to the elucidation of the commission of a criminal act resulting in death, will be accomplished. This article offers an update of the theme of the participation of the forensic physician at the scene of the crime, considering the reality of the medicolegal practice in Panamá.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

Clinical forensic medicine (CFM), as a single discipline, encompasses a number of areas of medico-legal practice including injury interpretation, management of sexual and physical assault cases (both adult and child; alleged victim and offender), mental health issues, traffic medicine, custodial medicine and toxicology. The cases are usually alive but in some jurisdictions the forensic practitioner also engages in death investigation with some undertaking autopsies. During the last 20-30 years, the discipline has fragmented with areas being hived off to other medical specialist disciplines and, importantly, to nurses. Any user of forensic services wants the best value for money particularly when under financial pressure. To this end, governments have sought savings through privitisation of services and/or the utilisation of less qualified personnel to undertake some or all of the tasks. This places CFM at a crossroads. To ensure survival, the discipline needs to reconsider its direction and performance, convince stakeholders of its relevance and importance, and lift its profile within the legal, academic and medical world. It will need to think outside the square, place greater emphasis on the 'clinical' and relinquish those activities that are better undertaken by less expensive and qualified personnel. The establishment of meaningful research and academic centres are essential. The loss of and/or failure to grow CFM will result in the loss of a skills base and the subsequent potential for the miscarriages of justice.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: Forensic physicians are responsible for first-line medical care of detainees (individuals held in custody) in the police station. The Dutch police law contains a 'duty of care', which gives the police responsibility for the apparent mentally ill and/or confused people they encounter during their work. The police can ask a forensic physician to do a primary psychiatric assessment of any apparent mentally ill detainee. The forensic physician determines if the apparent mentally ill behavior of the detainee is due to a somatic illness, or has a psychiatric cause for which the detainee needs admission to a psychiatric hospital. The forensic physician consults the second-line Public Mental Health Care (PMHC). OBJECTIVE: This study aims to give an overview of the outcomes of psychiatric assessments of apparent mentally ill detainees in police stations. These assessments were done by forensic physicians over a period of eight years (2005-2013). A distinction is made between mental disorders, social problems, and alcohol/drugs abuse. METHODS: All psychiatric assessments were registered in a medical database. When a secondary public mental health care assessment was performed, the conclusions and/or written feedback were received and included in the medical database. This information was used for this retrospective observational study. RESULTS: Of all the apparent mentally ill individuals brought by the police into the police station, the forensic physician sent home or referred 51.8% to their own respective caretakers or the individuals were voluntarily admitted to addiction care or other care facilities. When the forensic physician referred a detainee to PMHC, a compulsory admission to a psychiatric hospital was indicated by PMHC in 62.8% of the cases. Ultimately, of the total apparent mentally ill individuals brought in by the police 30.0% was admitted to a psychiatric hospital. DISCUSSION: Many apparent mentally ill individuals brought to the police station are sent home by the forensic physician. Before the psychiatric assessment, medical causes of psychiatric illnesses, for example excited delirium syndrome and hypoglycemia, drug use (GHB, cocaine, heroin), and cerebral pathology are excluded. The police perform as one of the channels through which the mentally ill get entrance to mental health care. Our data show no changes in the number of psychiatric assessments during 2005-2013.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

INTRODUCTION: Annually about 28% of the 5800 death of unnatural cause in the Netherlands are a result of suicide. In 2012 and 2013 a movie and a book were published about a "dignified end of life" which also described the suicide using the exit bag to establish asphyxia using helium. The purpose of this study is to investigate if the suicide methods changed since the publicity in 2013 about suicidal asphyxiation by using helium gas. This study especially focuses on suicide using the 'exit bag' with or without helium gas. MATERIAL AND METHODS: In the period 2005 to 2014 all suicides in the region of Amsterdam-Amstelland and Zaanstreek-Waterland were analyzed and from these suicides cases using the exit bag were selected. RESULTS: The study shows a rising trend with the use of the helium (P > 0.01) and a decreasing trend for suicide by asphyxia using an exit bag (P < 0.05). The data does not show a sudden difference, but there seems to be a gradually change. DISCUSSION: The number of suicides using the helium method is rising in Amsterdam-Amstelland and Zaanstreek-Waterland, while suicides by asphyxiation without helium are decreasing. The specific publicity of books about suicides using helium may have influenced this transition.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

PURPOSE: The goal of this study was to ascertain accordance between cause of death established by the forensic physician and autopsy results in young sudden death victims in the Netherlands. METHODS: Sudden death victims aged 1-45 years examined by forensic physicians operating in the participating regions which also underwent an autopsy between January 2006 and December 2011 were included (n = 70). Cause of death established by the forensic physician based on the external medicolegal examination was compared with autopsy findings using the ICD10-classification. RESULTS: Autopsy findings revealed that the majority of sudden death victims have died from a cardiac disease (n = 51, 73%). Most of the presumed heart disease related cases were confirmed by autopsy (n = 13, 87%). On the contrary, a large number of deaths caused by circulatory diseases were not recognised by the forensic physician (n = 38, 75%). In most of these cases, the forensic physician was forced to report an undetermined cause due to the lack of a solid explanation for death. Cause of death reported by the forensic physician appeared to be in agreement with the autopsy results in 12 cases (17%). CONCLUSIONS: Cause of death determination in young sudden death victims is a difficult task for forensic physicians due to the limited tools available during the medicolegal examination. An effort should be made to standardize extensive post-mortem investigation after sudden death in the young. Autopsy can provide valuable information regarding the cause of death, which is of great importance in view of the identification of inheritable diseases among decedents and their families.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

Este artigo apresenta resultados de pesquisa realizada no Núcleo de Medicina e Odontologia Legal (NUMOL) de Campina Grande (PB). Objetiva mostrar a atividade de trabalho, evidenciando os fatores de risco e as estratégias de defesa utilizadas para enfrentá-los e subvertê-los. Os pressupostos teóricos e metodológicos se basearam nas abordagens da Ergonomia Situada e da Psicodinâmica do Trabalho. Foram feitas 15 observações sistemáticas do trabalho e quatro entrevistas coletivas com as equipes do NUMOL. Identificaram-se os fatores de risco biossanitário, ergonômico, de acidentes e psicológico. Percebeu-se a mobilização dos trabalhadores diante das variabilidades, na cooperação no trabalho e na elaboração de estratégias de defesa. Concluiu-se que os trabalhadores são ativos, usam os saberes de prudência e elaboram estratégias de defesa para se proteger dos riscos e transformar o sofrimento.

This article presents the results of a research which took place in the NUMOL (Center for Forensic Medicine and Odontology) of Campina Grande (PB, Brazil). It shows the work activity and highlights the risk factors, as well as the defense strategies used to confront and transform such risks. The theoretical approaches and methods used are the Located Ergonomics and Work Psychodynamic. Fifteen work systematic observations and four interviews with NUMOL teams were made. We identified biohealth, ergonomic, psychological, and accident risk factors. It was realized that workers are mobilized in face of the work variability through work cooperation, developing defense strategies. It was concluded that workers are active and use their knowledge of prudence elaborating strategies to protect themselves from the risks of work and to transform the suffering.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

The aim of this systematic is to review and analyse the literature concerned with the health needs of detainees in police custody in England and Wales. The healthcare of detainees in police custody is regulated by the England and Wales Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984. The Faculty of Forensic and Legal Medicine of the Royal College of Physicians also sets quality standards for the provision of custodial healthcare. The provision of healthcare in custody presents a number of challenges including the patient group, the setting and the overlap between the legal and medical concerns that are addressed by the medical team. Currently, care to the detainees in custody is delivered by a mixture of private organisations, police-led forensic medical services and the NHS. A search of the PUBMED, EMBASE and PsycINFO databases undertaken using the search terms: (police custody) OR (detainees) OR (police detainees) yielded 830 publications. All of the titles were screened to identify potentially relevant publications concerned with the health needs of detainees in police custodies in England and Wales. There were no design specific criteria set for inclusion of the studies in this literature review. 77 articles were initially identified as relevant and obtained in full. After further analysis 28 publications were included in this literature review. A total sample of over 12,000 detainees was examined in this literature review. Approximately 20% of detainees seen by health care teams suffer from psychiatric conditions. On average, 50% of patients claim that they have problems with drugs and alcohol. Physical health conditions are also highly prevalent with up to 74% of detainees requiring regular medication. Forensic medical issues included the management of detainees who were restrained using handcuffs, irritant sprays and TASER. Detainees who are suspected of internal drug concealment also require intensive medical input. Injury documentation in custody is often requested for both the police officer and detainees. Current literature indicates that mental health problems including substance misuse and physical conditions are highly prevalent among the custody population and require both emergency and routine care. The current quality of the health-care services has been discussed and the need for improvement has been indicated by a number of agencies. Recent attempts have been made to incorporate the custodial services into the general structure of the NHS, aiming for more robust governance and standardization of services. Implementation of a routine health promotion service in custody has also been discussed which can be integrated into the general health care provision during detention.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

BACKGROUND: In many countries, forensic physicians function as primary care providers for detainees in police custody. Their task is comparable to the tasks of general practitioners. Nevertheless, problems presented by both patient populations may differ. We therefore aimed to systematically compare presented problems and medication use in a population of police detainees to those of regular patients in general practice. METHODS: Health problems and prescription medications of 3232 detainees seen by the Amsterdam Forensic Medical Service were compared to those of general practice patients (n = 78,975) adjusted for age and gender during a 12-month period. RESULTS: Among those obtaining medical attention (28% of all detainees), almost 50% were diagnosed with mental health problems, with substance abuse as the leading reason for consultation. Forty-two percent received at least one prescription affecting the nervous system. In general practice, 17% (P < 0.001) of patients consulting their GP were diagnosed with mental health problems and 22% (P < 0.001) were prescribed medications affecting the nervous system. CONCLUSION: The magnitude of mental health problems among police detainees has significant implications for the qualifications of police health staff and those who provide health care in the police setting especially concerning substance abuse.

Asunto(s)

RESUMEN

The provision of clinical forensic medicine services is dependent on jurisdiction and relevant legal instruments. A needs analysis was performed to understand the current service provision within NSW and compare and contrast the service with other jurisdictions in Australia. The aim of this study was therefore to identify the roles, functions and clinical forensic medical services currently provided in the different Australian jurisdictions.

Asunto(s)