RESUMEN
In 2009, the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office Forensic Biology Unit developed an innovative DNA backlog strategy to construct and operate a centralized biological processing laboratory (BPL) within a law enforcement agency, the Boca Raton Police Services Department. The BPL became fully operational in 2012 and obtained accreditation in 2017. This coordinated, multi-agency agreement resulted in a streamlined process exemplifying several benefits such as communicating timely testing results, decreasing the case turnaround time, and decreasing the DNA case backlog. This paper provides a summary of the necessary considerations of location, construction, personnel, and services when constructing a BPL, as well as, provides a comparison of initial completion dates and ultimate completion dates over a three-year period from 2016 to 2018. Three LEAs submitted 613 cases to the BPL commensurate with jurisdictional population. Performance metrics such as types and number of criminal cases screened; the number of samples forwarded for PBSO DNA testing; the turnaround time to handle, screen, or analyze a forensic sample; evidentiary samples; and the number of profiles entered into the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS) database are reported. For example, prior to this DNA backlog reduction strategy, the FBU was taking an average of 153 days to handle, screen, or analyze a forensic sample from submission to final report and there was a backlog of 679 cases. From 2016 to 2018, the total average turnaround time for BPL decreased from 30.5 to 19.6 days, (35.8% decrease); and the FBU Request turnaround time decreased from 153 to 80 days (35% decrease). Monitoring laboratory metrics demonstrate the efficacy of the DNA backlog reduction strategy. There are several takeaway lessons from this experience, including (1) engaging legal counsel early to outline necessary legal procedures and the timeline; (2) bringing all stakeholders "to the table" early to discuss expectations, as well as legal and operational responsibilities; and (3) creating a realistic timeline as well as establishing a comprehensive memorandum of understanding by which all parties understand their roles and responsibilities. Understanding laboratory and non-laboratory policy issues is critical to implementation success and the efficacy of a BPL as a DNA backlog reduction strategy.
RESUMEN
In August 2015, the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office (PBSO) initiated a CODIS-Based Sexual Assault Evidence Testing Initiative, hereto referred to as the Initiative, as a direct result of the ongoing national inquiry about the number of untested sexual assault cases having DNA evidence stored in law enforcement agency vaults. The Initiative was designed to research sexual assault related evidence including the estimated 1800 untested sexual assault kits stored in the custody of Palm Beach County Law Enforcement Agencies to determine if probative evidence was available, conduct DNA testing on the evidence, and enter all eligible DNA profiles into the CODIS database. Between December 2015 and July 2018 more than 5500 cases were researched and evaluated resulting in evidence from 1,558 cases spanning a 43-year period being tested at a cost of $1,032,496. Nearly 44% of all cases tested provided CODIS-eligible profiles and 36% of those eligible profiles generated a CODIS hit. The positive impact of this Initiative, while already realized by Initiative-related arrests, will continue to grow as additional CODIS hits are generated and investigated by PBSO law enforcement partners. Ultimately, the Initiative will provide information to criminal investigators and the courts including exonerating the innocent, bringing closure to victims, and helping convict the true perpetrators.