RESUMEN
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Primary radiotherapy is often preferred for early-stage cancer of the nasal vestibule (CNV), combining high disease control with preservation of nasal anatomy. However, due to practice variation and an absence of comparative trials, no consensus exists on preference for brachytherapy (BT) or external beam radiotherapy (EBRT). We compared these modalities in terms of disease control, nose preservation rates and toxicity. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Medical records of 225 patients with T1-T2 squamous cell carcinoma of the nasal vestibule treated with 3D image-guided primary radiotherapy between Jan 2010 and Dec 2016 in 6 Dutch institutions were reviewed retrospectively. RESULTS: 153 of 225 patients were treated with BT, 65 with EBRT and 7 with other modalities. Median follow-up was 46 months. Overall 3-year local control (LC) and regional control (RC) were 87% and 89%. Five-year disease-specific survival (DSS) and overall survival (OS) were 94% and 82%. Three-year survival with preserved nose (SPN) was 76%. BT provided higher 3-year LC (95% vs 71%, p < 0.01) and SPN compared with EBRT (82% vs 61%, p < 0.01). Multivariable and propensity-score-matched cohort analyses confirmed better outcomes after BT. No difference was seen in DSS or OS. Five-year incidence of CTCAE 5.0 grade ≥2 toxicity was higher after BT (20% vs 3%, p = 0.03) and consisted mostly of radiation ulcers. 50% of all late toxicity recovered. CONCLUSION: In this largest-to-date multicenter analysis of T1-T2 CNV, BT achieved superior LC and SPN compared with EBRT. Grade 1-2 radiation ulcers occurred more frequently after brachytherapy, but were transient in half the cases. Considering these results, BT can be recommended as first-line treatment for T1-T2 CNV.
Asunto(s)
Braquiterapia , Neoplasias de la Próstata , Radioterapia Guiada por Imagen , Braquiterapia/efectos adversos , Humanos , Masculino , Puntaje de Propensión , Estudios RetrospectivosRESUMEN
PURPOSE: To evaluate the efficacy of modern image guided brachytherapy for squamous cell carcinoma of the nasal vestibule, to explore tumor volume as a prognostic factor for local and regional recurrence, and to assess patient satisfaction with nasal function and appearance after treatment. METHODS AND MATERIALS: In a retrospective analysis, we reviewed the medical records of 102 patients with Wang T1-T2 nasal vestibule cancer treated at a single institution with brachytherapy as the sole treatment. Median follow-up time was 42 months (range, 3-210 months). A patient satisfaction study using the validated Nasal Appearance and Function Evaluation Questionnaire was conducted among 42 patients more than 1 year after treatment. A statistically significant cutoff point for tumor volume as a prognostic factor of local control was established using Youden's index method. RESULTS: Seventy-seven of 102 patients were treated with interstitial implants, and 25 patients were treated by an intracavitary mould technique. The 5-year control rates were 95%, 91%, and 83% for local, regional, and locoregional control, respectively. Tumor volume ≥2.3 cm3 resulted in worse 3-year regional control compared to tumor volume <2.3 cm3 (62% vs 96%; P = .01). Ultimate regional control after salvage treatment was 96%, with no significant difference observed between subgroups by tumor volume (92% for ≥2.3 cm3 vs 96% for <2.3 cm3; P = .57). Three patients with regional failure developed distant metastases. Five-year disease-specific survival and overall survival were 94% and 74%, respectively. Patient-assessed cosmetic and functional satisfaction were both rated high (mean 3.7 and 4.0 of 5, respectively). CONCLUSION: We report the largest cohort to date treated with brachytherapy as the sole treatment for nasal vestibule carcinoma. Brachytherapy offers excellent local control for Wang T1-T2 tumors with high patient satisfaction. Tumor volume is an adequate predictive factor for patients at risk of regional recurrence, but ultimate control rates after salvage treatment are high. Therefore, we do not recommend elective treatment of the neck.